Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

stopdiggin

(14,401 posts)
39. I guess we're going to argue definitions?
Mon Sep 15, 2025, 12:50 PM
Monday

Classmates (and teachers?) routinely describe Robinson as "quiet" and "noticeably 'smart" - and his academic achievement was (again) 'well above average'. Note, I did not label this person Mensa or genius level IQ. But, then - I don't think that necessary to qualify for my generalized 'well above .. '

But, more importantly - given what evidence we do have - I think I'll stick with my refutation of the, "Arrogant murderers probably don't have much of a brain" post that I responded to. In this case - that assertion would seem to be - well, frankly just flat out wrong! The kid was certainly no dummy. While, at the same time, performing horrible actions has little or nothing to do with 'having a brain'. And, taking both of those errors into account, the statement I objected veers far wider of the mark than my own poor statement.

Also - as you are doubtlessly aware - kids drop out of school for all kinds of reasons. And in fact - a lot of the time those reasons have nothing to do with academic 'ability'. And further - as you are also doubtlessly aware - it is an egregious mistake to attempt to tie 'coping', to anything like IQ or acuity. That's clearly false analogy.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

As Justice Robert Jackson said: rsdsharp Sunday #1
100% Anybody with half a brain ... - - -(nt)- stopdiggin Sunday #3
Damn, that eliminates this administration LiberalArkie Sunday #5
Arrogant murderers probably don't have much of a brain. nt Trueblue Texan Sunday #7
this person was apparently regarded as well above average ... stopdiggin Sunday #11
Reich-wing is pushing narrative he got radicalized at University, oops, he was only there one term. Bernardo de La Paz Monday #21
I guess we're going to argue definitions? stopdiggin Monday #39
WOW! ubermarg Sunday #2
I know right?!! yardwork Sunday #4
Post Building! FSogol Monday #22
This is the same governor that was praying the shooter was agingdem Sunday #6
But then later Diraven Sunday #8
Exactly BumRushDaShow Sunday #13
I guess white republican jesus wasn't in the mood to grant favors. ananda Sunday #16
Well, maybe he means this shooter won't bluestarone Sunday #9
Gaslighting.. agingdem Sunday #15
Translation: he has a really good lawyer who advised him to clam up Justice Brandeis Sunday #10
Yup Prairie Gates Monday #25
Jesus Christ, what a piss-poor public speaker. Aristus Sunday #12
What is he trying to say? taxi Sunday #14
What? He won't go along with the 'furry lover' scam? travelingthrulife Sunday #17
Utah governor sure loves himz's camera time. IA8IT Sunday #18
And you expect him to cooperate with LE, Cox? republianmushroom Sunday #19
Sounds like they haven't proffered a plea deal - life instead of the death penalty in exchange for a confession. LudwigPastorius Sunday #20
They are pursuing the Death Penalty... Happy Hoosier Monday #23
What in the hell? Prairie Gates Monday #24
He's stammering like a schoolboy Blues Heron Monday #27
Doesn't matter Prairie Gates Monday #28
Why would they do an "editorial correction" of what was actually said? BumRushDaShow Monday #30
It's not sane washing Prairie Gates Monday #32
"Standard journalistic practice" would be to paraphrase BumRushDaShow Monday #35
The last 100 years are history. maxsolomon Monday #38
I certainly agree that journalistic standards have fallen markodochartaigh Monday #29
Yes, inclusion of repetitions and filler words is always an attempt to deride the speaker Prairie Gates Monday #31
Makes me wonder if he has a stutter. mwmisses4289 Monday #37
Cox is such a piece of shit Blues Heron Monday #26
Flagged for libeling a very important substance. markodochartaigh Monday #33
Lol! Blues Heron Monday #34
It states he hasn't been formally charged. So why talk. miyazaki Monday #36
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Utah governor says allege...»Reply #39