Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

LetMyPeopleVote

(169,852 posts)
20. Deadline: Legal Blog-Trump wants to file a Supreme Court petition in E. Jean Carroll case this fall
Thu Sep 4, 2025, 11:52 AM
Sep 4

Lawyers representing the president want until Nov. 10 to file their petition challenging a lower court ruling in Carroll’s favor.

Trump wants to file a Supreme Court petition in E. Jean Carroll case this fall - MSNBC

apple.news/Ajr3BoZimQdW...

(@oc88.bsky.social) 2025-09-03T21:56:06.305Z

https://www.msnbc.com/deadline-white-house/deadline-legal-blog/e-jean-carroll-trump-appeal-supreme-court-rcna228869

The president’s lawyers said they intend to file a petition asking the justices to hear their bid to reverse an appeals court ruling in favor of E. Jean Carroll, the writer whom Trump was found to have sexually abused and defamed. Carroll won two similar civil cases against Trump: one that’s pending in the appeals court in which she won an $83.3 million defamation award, and another in which she won $5 million.

The latter case is the subject of Trump’s forthcoming Supreme Court petition, which will challenge an appeals court ruling against him. In an Aug. 27 filing, his lawyers asked for permission to extend their filing deadline from Sept. 11 to Nov. 10.

Extensions are normal in Supreme Court practice, and in the likely event that this one is granted, that wouldn’t signal that the court will necessarily agree to hear Trump’s appeal. It’s more of an administrative request simply to give his lawyers more time to file the petition. After they do, Carroll’s lawyers can file a brief opposing review, and then the court will decide whether to take it up. It takes four justices to agree to grant review.

“President Trump has consistently and unequivocally denied Carroll’s allegations in both cases,” his filing said. It didn’t fully lay out his forthcoming legal arguments (those will come in the petition), but it said his lawyers intend to raise issues involving how different courts of appeals address evidentiary issues. Parties seeking high court review often tell the justices that review is needed to resolve splits among lower courts around the country.

trump got his butt kicked in the trial court and there are jury findings that will be hard to overcome.

Recommendations

3 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Lets hope her lawyer is right-but then again, his buddies on the SC will probably conjure up riversedge Sep 4 #1
SCROTUS may just kick the can down the road until after next year's election. GreenWave Sep 4 #9
He really does see them as his personal lawyers, doesn't he? SomewhereInTheMiddle Sep 4 #2
And don't forget MyOwnPeace Sep 4 #17
And what about the millions that he also owes the state of New York for his years of business fraud? Rhiannon12866 Sep 4 #3
I was disappointed when the fraud penalty was overturned. John1956PA Sep 4 #4
He plans to "ask" or to "instruct?" Orrex Sep 4 #5
Trump will have the US Supreme Court exonerate him for any and all crimes and liabilities. Irish_Dem Sep 4 #6
I gotta say this for the SCOTUS-6: lastlib Sep 4 #7
It's absolutely disgusting mdbl Sep 4 #8
Someone said they follow the golden rule--- lastlib Sep 4 #10
Oh, never heard that phrase! Too true sometimes! electric_blue68 Sep 4 #38
I wonder how much they were paid to sell out their country and democracy? Irish_Dem Sep 4 #12
It is such a shock CozyMystery Sep 4 #27
The only acceptable verdict... lonely bird Sep 4 #11
Trump was sued as a private citizen edhopper Sep 4 #13
Never mind. He was sued in federal court. LeftInTX Sep 4 #28
Yes edhopper Sep 4 #30
"He's king" LeftInTX Sep 4 #31
"Please let me get away with assault and abuse." -Dump, probably sakabatou Sep 4 #14
Maybe the jury will have something to say about that................oh yeah they already did.................guilty..... turbinetree Sep 4 #15
If they do then he owns them. JohnnyRingo Sep 4 #16
The GOP love people who abuse women. Old Crank Sep 4 #18
Kavanaugh and Thomas are fine with abusing women. It's their hobby. Captain Zero Sep 5 #45
That predator is such a sore loser. Dave Bowman Sep 4 #19
Deadline: Legal Blog-Trump wants to file a Supreme Court petition in E. Jean Carroll case this fall LetMyPeopleVote Sep 4 #20
There's no earthly reason to "toss" this case FakeNoose Sep 4 #21
Oh, I love that Xmas Decoration! electric_blue68 Sep 4 #39
"And I want total PEDO immunity, too. Got that?" - Krassnov (r-moral exemplar for little repubes) BoRaGard Sep 4 #22
Trump thinks rules are for other people only neohippie Sep 4 #23
What a joke our legal system have become. republianmushroom Sep 4 #24
Never seen a president abuse his power and use the Supreme Court as his personal court Owens Sep 4 #25
If he's a billionaire like he says he is TexasBushwhacker Sep 4 #26
"I am king" LeftInTX Sep 4 #29
SCOTUS is corrupt... Snackshack Sep 4 #32
On what basis? North Coast Lawyer Sep 4 #33
Let them whine all they want HarryM Sep 4 #34
This message was self-deleted by its author Snackshack Sep 4 #35
Since When RobinA Sep 4 #36
This is certainly a court quite capable of legalizing rape. After all, it's a not that big a deal to a court that's... NNadir Sep 4 #37
Thomas and Kavanaugh are uncharged RAPISTS themselves. Captain Zero Sep 5 #46
True. NNadir Sep 5 #47
He's Such SCUM! Pay the money you rapist! electric_blue68 Sep 4 #40
hard to believe this stll goes on. He learned well from Roy Cohn. Use the system to exhaust every possible option. Evolve Dammit Sep 4 #41
$5 million is pocket change, compared to the money trump is making as president. Paladin Sep 4 #42
Documentary at Telluride bmichaelh Sep 4 #43
Supreme Court expected to rule that rape is ok if you are Trump or if the victim is a relative. twodogsbarking Sep 4 #44
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Trump plans to ask Suprem...»Reply #20