Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(160,228 posts)
15. Unless it is codified like that in the state Constitution
Thu Aug 14, 2025, 11:52 AM
Aug 14

the Legislature can pass whatever they want to "change the rules".

And if there is something in the state Constitution that specifies redistricting, then there are 2 ways to amend that - https://www.albanylaw.edu/government-law-center/amending-nys-constitution

(snip)

There are two methods of amending the New York State Constitution. The first is via a constitutional convention followed by voter approval or rejection of any amendments approved by the convention’s delegates. The second is via proposal and approval of an amendment in two consecutive sessions of the Legislature. This explainer is about the second method.

Under Article XIX, section 1, of the state Constitution, any amendment must first be proposed in the state Senate and Assembly. Following its proposal, the amendment must be referred to the New York State Attorney General. Within twenty days of that referral, the Attorney General is required to issue an opinion to the Legislature “as to the effect of such amendment or amendments upon other provisions of the constitution.”3 Upon receiving the opinion of the Attorney General, or if no opinion is received within twenty days, both houses of the Legislature may consider the proposal.

If adopted by a majority of the members of both houses, which is commonly known as the “first passage,” the proposed amendment must be presented a second time to the Legislature during “the next regular legislative session convening after the succeeding general election of members of the assembly….”4 Because Assembly members are elected every two years, the proposal may be presented either in the next regular legislative session immediately following the year of first passage or in the next regular legislative session convened in the second year following first passage, depending on when the next election takes place after the first passage.

Should the proposed amendment again be adopted by a majority vote in a newly elected Legislature, it must be submitted to the voters “in such manner and at such time as the legislature shall prescribe.”5

(snip)


They just went through this process between 2022 and 2024 and apparently have already started on it -

Hochul embraces gerrymandering in New York

By Bill Mahoney
08/04/2025 01:05 PM EDT

(snip)

Hochul has embraced changing New York’s process since the fight over the Lone Star State maps escalated last month. Other Democrats have gone along as well: New York lawmakers introduced a state constitutional amendment last week that would let Democrats make mid-decade adjustments to their maps before the 2028 election cycle.

(snip)

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

With JB as Gov and a huge Democratic majority in the General Assembly Chasstev365 Aug 14 #1
Was looking at the IL delegation BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #4
This is what I thought you were missing on the other thread FBaggins Aug 14 #11
Why have you put so much effort into knocking down every potential path to resistance BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #13
The effort isn't put into knocking down anything FBaggins Aug 14 #18
I will write a strongly worded letter to him orangecrush Aug 14 #25
NC is actually GOP controlled for the purposes of redistricting dsc Aug 14 #20
This is why I put this - BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #21
we aren't mixed dsc Aug 14 #22
If all this ends up a net gain for Dems, Supreme Court will insist it be reversed. If net gain for Repubs, they won't, thesquanderer Aug 14 #2
As long as the redistricting is either based on compliance with a state Constitution BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #5
Hard to believe that we have any Democrats out there who don't realize Baitball Blogger Aug 14 #3
"Republicans don't plan on coming back to traditional methods" speak easy Aug 14 #29
Unfortunately, NY can't redistrict in time onlyadream Aug 14 #6
Was looking at their Legislative session page BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #7
That wouldn't change the end date of the process FBaggins Aug 14 #8
Unless they allow for voters to vote on the referendum during their primary election BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #10
They can't FBaggins Aug 14 #12
Unless it is codified like that in the state Constitution BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #15
It is indeed codified in the state constitution FBaggins Aug 14 #17
The link mentiones "2 processes" to amend BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #19
The second process is even longer FBaggins Aug 14 #23
The the first option in the link was the "convention" BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #26
Given what Gov Hochul's said on air, yes, it's permitted. She's got the power to call any number of special sessions. ancianita Aug 14 #9
Thanks for clarifying that! onlyadream Aug 14 #14
I will tell you that BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #16
To be fair, the AI does give references where it got the info onlyadream Aug 14 #24
It's still is in an "embryonic" stage BumRushDaShow Aug 14 #27
YES... myohmy2 Aug 14 #28
Not a time for dragging one's feet. C Moon Aug 15 #30
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Newsom urges Illinois, NY...»Reply #15