Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Behind the Aegis

(56,113 posts)
31. When it comes to anything medical, he really should keep his mouth closed.
Sat Aug 15, 2020, 12:24 AM
Aug 2020

I like him, most of the time and don't expect him to be some goddamned paragon of virtue, but when medical issues abound, he usually misses the mark.

As for the "product of their times", that is what many were. He was wrong in claiming no one was against slavery, there were those against it for as long as it has existed in one form or another. However, the crux of the monologue was people need to get the fuck over themselves with "atoning" for every "sin" of the past, including those they didn't commit. He was also speaking to those "holier than thou" assholes who scream, stamp their feet, and shake their fists about how they couldn't have owned slaves, or aided the Nazis, or pushed Native Americans off their land. They are no different than historical revisionists in many respects. They take a modern, and mostly common, stance, and pretend they would have been the same person they are today even if they were born in 1820. While it is true, some here may not have wanted to own slaves, or been abolitionists, or stood up to the powers that be, but more often than not, they would have, possibly, looked like the liberals and progressives OF THE TIME, not of OUR time, and trust me, those "liberals" would NOT be liberals, for the most part, today. That is the point; though, IMO, he worded it in such a way that was convoluted and distracting.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

He's going to regret that uponit7771 Aug 2020 #1
He's been getting worse for quite awhile PatSeg Aug 2020 #2
and I don't know what he was trying to say when he said people who had slaves were a product of still_one Aug 2020 #5
I wonder if the quarantine is getting to him PatSeg Aug 2020 #13
Actually, that's an interesting possibility still_one Aug 2020 #24
He's lost it. He's gotten to be like Kanye West in that he says things for attention and... brush Aug 2020 #23
Attention getting is right. I think he jumped the shark tonight still_one Aug 2020 #25
Yes. He'll probably walk it back quietly next week as his show starts. brush Aug 2020 #28
He's always had alt-right (or alt-left) elements to his worldview, remember Coulter radius777 Aug 2020 #35
Well for a very long time PatSeg Aug 2020 #38
I love Maher, but that interview was not his finest moment. Music Man Aug 2020 #3
You love him? Maru Kitteh Aug 2020 #32
Yes, he's a great comedian and a Democrat at heart. Music Man Aug 2020 #39
Sadly he's lost his fastball BannonsLiver Aug 2020 #4
Mayor Pete, Yang, and Bottoms were great still_one Aug 2020 #6
She was great BannonsLiver Aug 2020 #7
Absolutely. Mayor Bottoms is always excellent still_one Aug 2020 #8
BTW BannonsLiver Aug 2020 #17
We are on the same page still_one Aug 2020 #21
If he had paid attention he would know how Cha Aug 2020 #10
"Someone more..." BannonsLiver Aug 2020 #16
The People voted for Joe Biden.. Democracy VS Cha Aug 2020 #20
Hasn't he read the reports of all the kids who are Cha Aug 2020 #9
It was crazy talk Cha. I though I was watching trump's new doctor, Atlas, who is spewing the still_one Aug 2020 #11
That's really too bad & dangerously disappointing. Cha Aug 2020 #14
It is very disappointing for sure, Cha BannonsLiver Aug 2020 #18
I stopped watching when he came back from last break. NCDem47 Aug 2020 #12
He had Colon Cowturd from Fox Sports on probably. Elwood P Dowd Aug 2020 #15
That's it. It was anti-science blathering still_one Aug 2020 #22
Yeah, his grasp of science is often flawed to weak misanthrope Aug 2020 #19
It sure is flawed still_one Aug 2020 #26
I didn't always agree with him but always respected his intellect MustLoveBeagles Aug 2020 #27
I imagine there will be a youtube excerpt of it soon enough where you can judge for yourself still_one Aug 2020 #29
I'll keep an eye out for it MustLoveBeagles Aug 2020 #30
When it comes to anything medical, he really should keep his mouth closed. Behind the Aegis Aug 2020 #31
BTA we agree 100% on the medical advice, and your description of his "product of our times" final still_one Aug 2020 #33
Thanks for the warning. I had considered watching tonight's episode ecstatic Aug 2020 #34
The guests he had on were excellent except for the fox sports guest at the end, who is another still_one Aug 2020 #36
Maher makes most of his money doing stand up Trumpocalypse Aug 2020 #37
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Bill Maher is a fucking i...»Reply #31