Philosophy

ZombieHorde

(29,047 posts)

10. I'm going to contrast John Stuart Mill with Marque de Sade.

Sat Apr 6, 2013, 09:13 AM

Apr 2013

John Stuart Mill would say that we should do what is best for the most people. Since capital punishment currently requires more resources than life in prison, and life in prison is safer for those who may be wrongfully convicted, life in prison would be the best choice for everyone. Our emotions wouldn't really be a big part of our decision.

Marque de Sade would say we should only punish someone if that punishment brings us pleasure. So if knowing that Ohio man was put to death brought you pleasure, then that would be the right option for you.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

21 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

My first impression... [View all] rrneck Apr 2013 OP

to ask why one does/feels something, isn't this the question that holds us Tuesday Afternoon Apr 2013 #1

Ain't it the truth. rrneck Apr 2013 #7

The fate of each of us... discntnt_irny_srcsm Apr 2013 #2

Thread win. rrneck Apr 2013 #5

An interesting question discntnt_irny_srcsm Apr 2013 #9

thanks for posting this Kali Apr 2013 #3

Beggars the imagination doesn't it? rrneck Apr 2013 #4

I agree with what you say about punishment Kali Apr 2013 #6

The burned hand teaches best. rrneck Apr 2013 #8

I'm going to contrast John Stuart Mill with Marque de Sade. ZombieHorde Apr 2013 #10

clarify this phrase, please - and thanks ZombieHorde Tuesday Afternoon Apr 2013 #11

When someone is given a death sentence in the US, they are entitled ZombieHorde Apr 2013 #12

I thought that was what you meant ... do you have a link for that? Tuesday Afternoon Apr 2013 #13

This website looks at some indivudual states and the federal government. ZombieHorde Apr 2013 #14

I've always found rrneck Apr 2013 #15

It's very unsatisfying to me as we'll ismnotwasm Apr 2013 #16

I mostly chose them because it was easy to argue from those perspectives, and I dislike Kant. ZombieHorde Apr 2013 #20

Both are wrong, imo, and the second is ridiculous. Dash87 Apr 2013 #18

Consider the meat culture in first-world countries. ZombieHorde Apr 2013 #19

That's true, but maybe we're all morally wrong for Dash87 Apr 2013 #21

First response - Emotional. Dash87 Apr 2013 #17