Football

caraher

(6,332 posts)

35. That was a good trade for both teams

Sat Oct 19, 2024, 01:33 PM

Oct 2024

It was March 2021

Hard to argue with winning a Super Bowl, and the Lions have been most un-Lion-like the past two seasons. Would the Rams have won with Goff rather than Stafford? Maybe.

And here's what it looked like for the Lions:

Lions lost:

QB Matthew Stafford
2022 34th overall pick (second round)
2022 66th overall pick (third round)
2023 81st overall pick (third round)
2023 122nd overall pick (fourth round)
2023 139th overall pick (fifth round)

Lions gained:

QB Jared Goff
WR Jameson Williams (first round, 12th overall)
RB Jahmyr Gibbs (first round, 12th overall)
TE Sam LaPorta (second round, 34th overall)
DL Josh Paschal (second round, 46th overall)
DT Brodric Martin (third round, 96th overall)
DB Ifeatu Melifonwu (third round, 101st overall)

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

38 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Name an NFL trade that's worse than Deshaun Watson [View all] Auggie Oct 2024 OP

It was a very siccessful trade - werdna Oct 2024 #1

I can at least match it. LakeVermilion Oct 2024 #2

Pretty close. Walker only played two season for the Vikings ... Auggie Oct 2024 #5

1989 Herschel Walker trade displacedvermoter Oct 2024 #3

Yep. 3 key players in the Cowboys rebuild underpants Oct 2024 #17

Babe Ruth going to the Yankees gab13by13 Oct 2024 #4

NFL, not MLB. But that was bad one for Boston. Auggie Oct 2024 #7

Guess we'll have to count on the Guardians to bring honor to Cleveland ...... the Dawgs sure won't. Diamond_Dog Oct 2024 #6

Guardians have good ownership and a good front office ... doing more with less. Auggie Oct 2024 #10

Yes. Haslams don't seem to be as astute as the Dolans and Antonetti. Diamond_Dog Oct 2024 #13

Dee Haslam took credit for vetting Watson ... Auggie Oct 2024 #15

..... Diamond_Dog Oct 2024 #16

Browns getting what they deserve by constantly hiring sexual predators. we can do it Oct 2024 #27

Paul Warfield for Mike Phipps. Botany Oct 2024 #8

I remember the sting of that ... Auggie Oct 2024 #11

You forgot to list Phipp's accomplishments! -misanthroptimist Oct 2024 #19

This message was self-deleted by its author Wiz Imp Oct 2024 #21

Probably wasn't worse but TheFarseer Oct 2024 #9

Ditka bragged that after the deal his day was done and headed for the golf course Auggie Oct 2024 #12

Champ Bailey was the only good player out of all those traded draft picks, so it was kind of a wash. Marcuse Oct 2024 #28

Ricky williams and herschel walker MontanaFarmer Oct 2024 #14

What's crazy about the Herschel Walker and Rick Williams trade... genxlib Oct 2024 #18

" It will probably affect the quality of that team for at least a decade." Auggie Oct 2024 #22

As an additional cost of the trade, Denver now leads the NFL in dead money on the payroll. Marcuse Oct 2024 #29

Probably not quite as bad, but still pretty terrible - Russell Wilson Wiz Imp Oct 2024 #20

I didn't realize about the Wilson trade being so costly displacedvermoter Oct 2024 #23

This message was self-deleted by its author Wiz Imp Oct 2024 #25

I guess True Dough Oct 2024 #24

Russel Wilson to Denver fits the bill Bristlecone Oct 2024 #26

Panthers trading up to take Bryce Young last year. Angleae Oct 2024 #30

Amazing how one dumb trade can kill one team and totally build another Auggie Oct 2024 #31

Yup. Morbius Oct 2024 #34

And Stefanski still refuses to move off of Watson as the starter True Dough Oct 2024 #32

Goff for Stafford? Brother Buzz Oct 2024 #33

That was a good trade for both teams caraher Oct 2024 #35

Goff just delivered another exciting come from behind victory! - Against the Vikings! Brother Buzz Oct 2024 #36

Watson was carted off the field today True Dough Oct 2024 #37

He's not the first, that's for sure Auggie Oct 2024 #38