Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Bluetus

(1,422 posts)
7. Sorry, I don't follow your rant.
Sun Aug 3, 2025, 12:37 PM
Aug 3

Renewables meet our energy needs without adding carbon to the atmosphere, and it makes zero difference whether you are talking watts or joules.

The only "scam" here is that we are still subsidizing the fossil fuel industry when both wind and solar are cheaper than ANY fossil fuel source, even without factoring in the externalities.

We should be leading the world in R&D AND DEPLOYMENT of carbon-free, radiation-free energy. (Wind and solar are both nuclear sources, but without the 10,000 year problem of waste disposal) We don't need a single drop of petroleum for energy, a single bucket of coal or a single case of cancer caused by nuclear accidents. We have everything necessary for a complete transition to clean energy -- everything except a way to wrestle control of our government from the fossil and nuke industries.

I should add that wind and solar generation have been cheaper than fossil fuels (even without counting externalities) for almost a decade. But the big issue was how to handle usage peaks and generation dips (when the sun is down or winds are mild). That problem is well within our grasp now with the emergence of Na-ion batteries. These are like lithium batteries, except they are 100% safe and are made almost entirely of very cheap, plentiful elements. We are nearing the point where we can deploy these batteries at scale throughout the grid. It will require billions of dollars of capital investment, but we just saw Musk/DOGE waste almost $30 billion in 90 days. Why aren't we putting that money into solutions that will help EVERYBODY.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Despite the misleading slick ad from the fossil fuel industry, China's hydrogen is overwhelmingly made from fossil fuels NNadir Aug 2 #1
I wold not call it a scam Bluetus Aug 2 #2
Europe has been working on this for some time OKIsItJustMe Aug 2 #4
And then, this article about "hydrogen powder" Bluetus Aug 3 #6
They make a comparison to "green ammonia" OKIsItJustMe Aug 3 #9
I'm not impressed by the dishonest use of units of POWER to substitute for units of ENERGY. NNadir Aug 3 #5
Sorry, I don't follow your rant. Bluetus Aug 3 #7
Generally people who can't "follow" this sort of thing endorse solar and wind. NNadir Aug 3 #8
Once again, I cannpt follow your stream of riddles. Bluetus Aug 3 #10
They're not "riddles." They're DATA and historical reports on the cost of energy during Dunkleflaute. NNadir Aug 3 #11
Post removed Post removed Aug 3 #12
Your first simile comes closest OKIsItJustMe Aug 3 #14
This "conversation," such as it is, is concluded. NNadir Aug 3 #15
I will take your challenge. OKIsItJustMe Aug 3 #13
Thank you kindly for this nice succinct correct statement of my views. NNadir Aug 19 #17
I'm glad you feel I accurately summarized your views OKIsItJustMe Aug 19 #18
System Analysis: Hydrogen production from nuclear energy OKIsItJustMe Aug 19 #19
Thank you for sharing, but I have many hundreds of papers on various thermochemical hydrogen cycles going... NNadir Aug 20 #20
I also have been familiar with "Nuclear Hydrogen" for decades OKIsItJustMe Aug 20 #21
The highlighted statement or a variant is similar if not identical to those... NNadir Aug 21 #22
"Soothsaying" OKIsItJustMe Aug 21 #23
"... object to me continuously producing the following table ..." OKIsItJustMe Aug 4 #16
Hydrogen can be mixed with "natural gas" much as ethanol can be mixed with gasoline OKIsItJustMe Aug 2 #3
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»"Green Hydrogen Is Finall...»Reply #7