Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

jmowreader

(52,822 posts)
119. Die Hard meets all the requirements to be a Christmas movie
Wed Dec 3, 2025, 06:33 PM
19 hrs ago

1. A proper Christmas movie is set during the Christmas season. While there are a few films that are considered Christmas movies but are not set at Christmastime, like The Sound of Music, a Christmas movie is generally set during the season. Die Hard, and at least one of its sequels, is set during Christmastime.

2. The accoutrements of Christmas, like decorations and Christmas parties, should be present. Die Hard is the story of a Christmas movie gone extremely wrong.

3. There should be a family conflict that resolves itself by the end of the movie. In Die Hard, New York City Police officer John McClane's wife had moved to Los Angeles for work, and tensions are high in the McClane family because of it.

4. A character should have some personal demons he or she gets rid of by the end of the movie. Serving as the distant end of John's radio calls is Sergeant Al Powell, who works a desk because he shot a kid during an incident and can't bring himself to pull his gun when necessary.

5. There should be a villain. Die Hard has three: the declared villain Hans Gruber, the TV news guy Dick Thornburgh, and Deputy Chief Dwayne Robinson. Quite frankly, Hans Gruber is the least odious of the three.

6. There needs to be a situation that suspends belief. Die Hard has a few. First is PG&E's need to take out a huge block of the city's power grid to cut the lights in Nakatomi Tower. You mean they can't just go over there and pull the meter head? Second is the FBI's theory that if they cut power to Nakatomi Tower it'll kill the lights inside; any commercial building has emergency lights that are powered by batteries for just such an occasion. Third, the vault? Lemme ask you something: if you were going to break into a Super High Tech Vault like Nakatomi had, would you spend hours trying to defeat the "seven seals" that it has or would you just walk in with a firefighter's breaching saw and cut a hole in the door? Sometimes the most efficient solution is brute force and ignorance.

7. There should be a character placed for comic relief. Argyle the Limo Driver is the man of Condition 7.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Several, Deb SheltieLover Tuesday #1
Thank you very much, SheltieLover. Love them debm55 Tuesday #16
It usually was an Easter movie when I was growing up. applegrove Tuesday #2
Thank you applegrove, I now watch both times on my tablet. debm55 Tuesday #4
Joyeux Noel--a must watch. pandr32 Tuesday #3
Thank you very much, pandr32. debm55 Tuesday #5
Trading Places EYESORE 9001 Tuesday #6
Oh you, Thank you EYESORE 9001, debm55 Tuesday #17
Die hard Blue dot in KS Tuesday #51
It is if you want it to be. I did not see it, So I can't answer that. Sorry, Blue dot in KS debm55 Tuesday #53
Die Hard meets all the requirements to be a Christmas movie jmowreader 19 hrs ago #119
Thank you jmowreader. You seem to have all bases covered. debm55 19 hrs ago #120
A Christmas without Snow 4TheArts Tuesday #7
I will, thank you very much, 4TheArts. I will try it. debm55 Tuesday #18
The Godfather Bluestocking Tuesday #8
Thank you Bluestocking for sharing with us. debm55 Tuesday #19
This message was self-deleted by its author debm55 Tuesday #55
Thank you Bluestocking for sharing your selection. debm55 Tuesday #59
White Christmas. rsdsharp Tuesday #9
Thank you very much, rsesharp. I love that song. debm55 Tuesday #26
HOLIDAY INN justaprogressive Tuesday #10
Thank you very much, justaprogressive for sharing with us. I have seen both of them and I agree. debm55 Tuesday #24
A Christmas Carol (1938 version) 50 Shades Of Blue Tuesday #11
Thank you very much, That version is the best. TY 50 Shades Of Blue. debm55 Tuesday #25
I love Ernest Saves Christmas JMCKUSICK Tuesday #12
Thank you ,John ,I don't think I have ever seen it before. I will need to go to YouTube and see if it is on there. debm55 Tuesday #23
Earnest Saves Christmas in on YouTube, Debbie Niagara Tuesday #37
Thank you very much for sharing that with us. Niagara. You are the best. debm55 Tuesday #60
White Christmas ⛄ MustLoveBeagles Tuesday #13
Thank you very much MustLoveBeagles. May the memories of your grandfather be a blessing to you. debm55 Tuesday #21
Thank you MustLoveBeagles Tuesday #22
"A Charlie Brown Christmas" I love Vince Guaraldi's music and especially all the kids ice skating scene... hlthe2b Tuesday #14
Like this one too MustLoveBeagles Tuesday #15
Love it , Thank you very much. hithe2b. debm55 Tuesday #20
Die Hard? EarthAbides Tuesday #27
Now you did it! Endlessmike56 Tuesday #29
Thank you EarthAbides. debm55 Tuesday #36
White Christmas is my favorite, Endlessmike56 Tuesday #28
Thank you very much for your selection. Endlessmike56. debm55 Tuesday #61
A Christmas Story get the red out Tuesday #30
We watch this every Christmas. Thank you very much for sharing get the red out. debm55 Tuesday #66
A Christmas Story, Bells of St. Mary's, The Man Who Came to Dinner Raven123 Tuesday #31
Thank you very much for sharing your selections. Raven123. debm55 Tuesday #34
A Christmas Carol Big Blue Marble Tuesday #32
Thank you very much for sharing with us, Big Blue Marble. debm55 Tuesday #33
A Christmas Carol from 1950 choie Tuesday #35
Thank you very much for sharing with us. choie. debm55 Tuesday #70
Moonstruck terip64 Tuesday #38
Thank you very much, terip64 debm55 Tuesday #62
Miracle on 34th Street CanonRay Tuesday #39
Thank you very much, CanonRay. I have seen many times. debm55 Tuesday #71
Both versions! Dear_Prudence Tuesday #82
MY favorites are the following: Niagara Tuesday #40
Eyes Wide Shut - great Christmas flick! beaglelover Tuesday #41
Can you explain to me in what way? Thank you very much beaglelover. debm55 Tuesday #42
There's a Christmas tree in EVERY SINGLE scene. No shit, there really is! beaglelover Tuesday #43
Thank you. beaglelover. debm55 Tuesday #86
A weak story in spots, but I love how that movie is lit. Xavier Breath Yesterday #109
I almost hate to say this but here goes.... MuseRider Tuesday #44
Thank you very much, MuseRider for sharing. And get better. debm55 Tuesday #72
Thank you! MuseRider Tuesday #85
Casablanca, followed by the Third Man, Citizen Kane, and Holiday ... marble falls Tuesday #45
Thank you marble falls. excellent choices. I remember reading that Cary Grant was member of the circus in England. debm55 Tuesday #74
Gremlins LogDog75 Tuesday #46
My sick sense of humor, but I enjoyed it, Thank you LogDog75 debm55 Tuesday #76
The Ref. NNadir Tuesday #47
Thank you very much for sharing NNadir. debm55 Tuesday #50
A Christmas Carol (Alastair Sim version) mvd Tuesday #48
Glad to see you Matt. It's been a long time. The political forum make me nervous. Your version on Scrooge is the best. debm55 Tuesday #49
We watched that on tv the year I had just turned 4. Tanuki Tuesday #78
A Christmas Carol 1938, White Christrmas, Preachers Wife redstatebluegirl Tuesday #52
Thank you very much for your selections, redstatebluegirl. debm55 Tuesday #69
Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol no_hypocrisy Tuesday #54
I watched that version every year as a kid. It sort of disappeared. Thank you no_hypocrisy. debm55 Tuesday #68
The Bishop's Wife DingleBerryNW Tuesday #56
Thank you very much, You took me back to watching as a child. debm55 Tuesday #65
Since no one has mentioned The Lion in Winter... CBHagman Tuesday #57
Thank you CBHagman. Excellent movie. debm55 Tuesday #63
Love actually. FalloutShelter Tuesday #58
Thank you FalloutShelter. debm55 Tuesday #64
Welcome Deb. FalloutShelter Tuesday #67
Elf is my favorite holiday movie. waterwatcher123 Tuesday #73
I love it too. Thank you very much waterwatcher123. debm55 Tuesday #75
I Don't Even Think of it as "Christmas Music," But "The Sound of Music" Wrestled It's Way Into My Mental The Roux Comes First Tuesday #77
Thank you very much, The Roux Comes First. I absolutely love that opening scene of Maria sing the title song. I first debm55 Tuesday #79
Muppet Christmas Carol Rizen Tuesday #80
When my son was very young we would watch that together. Thank you so much for bringing it up. Rizen debm55 Tuesday #81
Rudolf the Red Nose Reindeer Dear_Prudence Tuesday #83
My number two favorite. Thank you Dear_Prudence., Love you,deb debm55 Tuesday #84
Alistair Sim's Christmas Carol, and I love Bill Murray's Scrooge electric_blue68 Tuesday #87
Thank you very much for sharing you Christmas selections., electric_blue68, debm55 Yesterday #98
Not movies, but the Rankin-Bass TV Specials Wiz Imp Yesterday #88
The Year Without a Santa Claus is so awesome!! Coventina Yesterday #97
Thank you very much, for sharing with us, Coventina. Perfect. debm55 Yesterday #100
Thank you very much for sharing. Wiz Imp. Those are my favorites too. debm55 Yesterday #99
Meet Me In St. Louis Wiz Imp Yesterday #89
Thank you very much Wiz Imp. Yes, Judy and the song were beautiful debm55 Yesterday #94
Most of my favorites are from my childhood, so mostly animated cartoons RazorbackExpat Yesterday #90
I am so sorry. RazorbackExpat. Back then you had to wait a whole year to see it again. Bummer. debm55 Yesterday #95
Back then, years lasted longer than they do now RazorbackExpat 20 hrs ago #115
2 more I haven't seen mentioned Wiz Imp Yesterday #91
thank you very much, Wiz Imp for sharing with us. debm55 Yesterday #96
Bad Santa - 2003 - Comedy/Drama ‧ Emile Yesterday #92
Thank you so much for sharing with us Emile. debm55 20 hrs ago #116
I like so many of these mentioned here! I love "The Snowman" which is an animated short film based on Raymond Briggs' KitFox Yesterday #93
Thank you very much KitFox. for sharing. PS "the hills are alive with the sound of music." debm55 Yesterday #101
Remember the Night Tiny Tabby Yesterday #102
Thank you very much. Tiny Tabby.for sharing with us. I will have to see if it is on my Tablet to stream. debm55 Yesterday #105
The tv movie A House Without a Christmas Tree. Sneederbunk Yesterday #103
Thank you very much , Sneederbunk. I will make a check for it on my tablet. debm55 Yesterday #107
I met the real Maria Von Trapp many years ago at the avebury Yesterday #104
Oh wow. That you very much for sharing that with us, avebury debm55 Yesterday #106
The House Without a Christmas Tree subterranean Yesterday #108
Thank you very much, subterranean. I will take a look for it. debm55 23 hrs ago #111
It's available on two different Youtube channels, but... subterranean 22 hrs ago #112
Thank you. subterranean for sharing with us. debm55 21 hrs ago #113
Christmas Vacation. Xavier Breath Yesterday #110
Thank you very much Xavier Breath. That sounds like fun. I have never seen it. debm55 20 hrs ago #117
Two comedies. boonecreek 21 hrs ago #114
They will be on my to watch list--I love musicals and comedies. Thank you boonecreek. debm55 20 hrs ago #118
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Do you have a favorite ho...»Reply #119