Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

jgmiller

(661 posts)
35. Prop 50 Ammends the State Constitution
Thu Nov 13, 2025, 08:51 PM
Thursday

so they can't argue it violates the CA constitution which prevents mid-census redistricting. I mean they can try to argue it but it would fail because the citizens voted it in and in CA the citizens are allowed to ammend the constitution.

What they are arguing is that it is racially biased redistricting which means that they are trying to give SCOTUS a reason to rule in favor of Lousiana in their redistricting battle that was ordered to comply with the Voting Rights Act. In that case they are claiming the redemy itself violates the law against racial redistricting. The difference is that in Lousiana's case the remedy is actually intended to be racially biased and in CA's case it's not and instead intended to be politically biased. The thing is if you look at the new map it's going to be very hard to prove that, CA is approximately 39% Latino and many of the new districts that are tilted to Dems have a % of Latino population under 39% and the ones that are over were alredy Dem districts.

I seriously doubt a group as smart and Newsom's is going to do something as reckless and obvious as what Texas did. They thought this through and proving racial biased is going to be incredibly difficult.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Losing loser will lose in court. Nt Fiendish Thingy Thursday #1
If he wins WmChris Thursday #13
SCOTUS has already ruled TX redistricting is OK. Nt Fiendish Thingy Thursday #17
That's true. Problem is THIS court you can NOT depend on any decisions being the same bluestarone Thursday #22
Remember when you sometime went days without a news story about the President? twodogsbarking Thursday #2
remember those days very fondly rurallib Thursday #3
Sometimes on their days off they would visit troops or invite them to the White House, when there was a White House twodogsbarking Thursday #4
And the DOJ is suing Texas in 3 ...2....1.... (LOL) ificandream Thursday #5
We wouldn't have to do this shit if the GOP would stop letting Fox fill their heads with garbage. Initech Thursday #41
Can't wait to hear Newsom (and his lawyer's) response to this... hlthe2b Thursday #6
Oh this is just hysterical that they are claiming racial gerrymandering jgmiller Thursday #7
Redistricting bromeando Thursday #8
Elections are under the control of the several states. MLWR Thursday #9
If it goes to the Supreme Court Jesters, I'm sure they'll side w the orange beast. C Moon Thursday #10
turnabout is fair play. can we do the same to texas? Javaman Thursday #11
Texas doesn't have mid-term anti-redistricting in their state constitution... Wounded Bear Thursday #18
"...here in Texas I didn't get a chance to vote on shit." rubbersole Thursday #24
So true! LOL Javaman Thursday #25
"constitutional issues at stake in the challenge"? BaronChocula Thursday #12
It's the state constitution at issue...nt Wounded Bear Thursday #19
Actually, they aren't arguing over state statutes BaronChocula Thursday #28
Oh no, not the full weight of the Keystone Cops. Buddyzbuddy Thursday #14
Your tax dollars at work here. lees1975 Thursday #15
They're making it racial. Saying that CA redistricting favors Hispanics. ChicagoTeamster Thursday #16
The majority in the state of CA ARE Hispanic. BumRushDaShow Thursday #20
I know, but that's the basis of the Republican complaint same as lawsuits against schools that consider race ChicagoTeamster Thursday #21
That argument will fail BumRushDaShow Thursday #23
Trump's entire life including his Presidency is all about suing people. walkingman Thursday #26
The Texas state laws allow gerrymandering between censuses. Mblaze Thursday #27
Irony is that the citizens of California were allowed to vote to allow this but the ones in Texas were not. cstanleytech Thursday #30
I revisited California law Mblaze Thursday #37
If this is Unconstitutional then so is the redistricting in Texas. cstanleytech Thursday #29
Why doesn't he just fucking die already? Orrex Thursday #31
The Gop is doing it to North Carolina! CarolinaNC Thursday #32
Aw hell, let's all just become COL Mustard Thursday #33
No suing Texas or Missouri Historic NY Thursday #34
Prop 50 Ammends the State Constitution jgmiller Thursday #35
And the don't see the irony question everything Thursday #36
all TRUMP KNOWS how to do is sue YoshidaYui Thursday #38
Talk about balls! Playingmantis Thursday #39
We wouldn't have to do this if the GOP would stop letting Fox News dictate policy. Initech Thursday #40
I cannot wait to see how discovery goes. OldBaldy1701E 18 hrs ago #42
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Trump administration sues...»Reply #35