A few rare ones are somewhat valuable. From Google AI:
AOL CDs are generally not valuable, except for a few rare, early discs and specific designer or promotional versions that are collected by a small niche of enthusiasts. While the mass-produced, common AOL discs from the 1990s are considered worthless to the general public, highly sought-after collector's items can sell for a few dollars to over $100, and some designer discs have fetched higher prices.
What makes some AOL discs valuable?
Early editions: The very first AOL discs, particularly those from the mid-1990s, are rarer and more desirable to collectors.
Designer discs: AOL also produced limited-edition designer discs, some with celebrity or brand collaborations, which are sought after by collectors.
Promotional discs: Special promotional discs, such as those for specific retailers or events, can also have higher value due to their limited availability.
Sealed or pristine condition: Discs that have never been opened or used are generally more valuable to collectors than used ones.
How to check the value of your AOL CDs:
Identify the disc: Look for identifying marks, such as version numbers, dates, or special logos, to determine its rarity.
Search online marketplaces: Use platforms like eBay to see what similar rare discs are selling for.
Join collector communities: Engage with online collector groups on platforms like Reddit or dedicated collector websites to get information on rare finds and potential buyers.
In summary: While most AOL discs are worthless, some specific, rare, and early or promotional editions have become collectible items for a niche audience.