Announcements
In reply to the discussion: We are making some changes to the moderating/jury system. (THIS IS IMPORTANT.) [View all]quinnox
(20,600 posts)I don't think the 6-0 penalty of losing alerts is good enough any longer under this new system. They should lose their alerting privileges for a period of time, if they lose on their alerts say, 4 or 5 times in a row. That way, it would discourage frivolous alerting or alert stalking.
Or your idea is good too, where bad jury results could be appealed. I think I like that better. You would get a certain amount of limited appeals, say, one a week, for example, if you thought your jury hide was off base. Then, admins could reverse the hide, if they thought it merited it. Of course, this would result in a lot more work for admins. So, another way could be the appeal would get you 6 new jurors and your hidden post would be re-judged in the jury pool. That way, your hidden post would have to be hidden twice when you used an appeal.
Edited many times to fix errors, because I just woke up, and can barely put words together.
Edit history
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):