General Discussion

Kaleva

(40,407 posts)

18. The Civil War was a numbers game Lee couldn't win

Reply to Norbert (Original post)

Sat May 2, 2026, 11:58 AM

Saturday

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

rampartd

50 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Idiot: If it weren't for Gettysburg, Robert E Lee would have won (the Civil War). [View all] Norbert Saturday OP

He knows nothing about history except for a few names. Haggard Celine Saturday #1

Pootin SheltieLover Saturday #4

Yep, he's the only one with any brains, and he Haggard Celine Saturday #7

Yup! SheltieLover Saturday #8

And his looney versions of history PatSeg Saturday #25

Dupe oops PatSeg Saturday #26

There's a long list of who is running things. wnylib Saturday #39

Loser Whip-poor-will Saturday #2

Lee got his ass kicked in his first combat command Mysterian Saturday #3

Lee's only concern was protecting his plantation and his Virginia buddies . haele Saturday #44

Kegbreath disgusts actual fighting men Mysterian Saturday #48

So he is asking edhopper Saturday #5

I think it was a combination of the Union win at Gettysburg and Haggard Celine Saturday #9

Right you are edhopper Saturday #23

Disagree ITAL Saturday #27

The funny thing is Iran is doing to Trump what the South should have done edhopper Saturday #24

If it weren't for losing, he would have won. n/t Mister Ed Saturday #6

"The amateurs discuss tactics: the professionals discuss logistics. " - Napoleon Bonaparte Girard442 Saturday #10

Yes, but then he tried to ram the ramparts, and storm the airports . . . hatrack Saturday #11

Yes,... and General Lee drove around the Gettysburg War Battlefield,... magicarpet Saturday #32

If it hasn't been for the Indians Dan Saturday #12

Look around. The Confederacy seems to have won. Kid Berwyn Saturday #13

Traitor rooting for a traitor dalton99a Saturday #14

"Nice ballroom you're planning there TACO, be a real shame if somethin' happened to it!"--General Sherman RedWhiteBlueIsRacist Saturday #15

Lee never won outside of Virginia. Sneederbunk Saturday #16

The Western theater is where Grant showed his stuff Martin Eden Saturday #19

And the 20th Maine, who did the fighting Mysterian Saturday #20

Yes, Jeff Daniels was great in that role in the movie Martin Eden Saturday #22

Pander pander pander Oneironaut Saturday #17

The Civil War was a numbers game Lee couldn't win Kaleva Saturday #18

General Bonespurs has spoken Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Saturday #21

TRANSLATION: Bigot in Chief Mourns South's Loss of Civil War B.See Saturday #28

Lee's leadership averted a much worse tragedy at the Bowling Green Massacre. Girard442 Saturday #29

Robert E. Lee: I will send an army uphill over 2 miles of open ground against an entrenched position Prairie Gates Saturday #30

Sounds like Putin's plan for Ukraine and his for Iran. doc03 Saturday #31

This is a very, very sick man. legallyblondeNYC Saturday #33

"If it weren't for the fact they lost, the South could have won! Big strong men with tears in their eyes struggle4progress Saturday #34

And, If McLellan Hadn't Been Such A Tool.... ProfessorGAC Saturday #35

Doubtful Cirsium Saturday #38

Silly ProfessorGAC Saturday #43

Why do that? Cirsium Saturday #45

the lost cause Cirsium Saturday #36

US Grant nailed it: anamnua Saturday #41

Speaking of the lost cause mythos anamnua Saturday #42

Written by Robbie Robertson of The Band Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Saturday #46

agreed Cirsium Saturday #47

History from the dumbest president ever elected. spanone Saturday #37

Lee got his ass handed to him by the Minnesota 1st regiment NickB79 Saturday #40

"I give it a year before the revisionist 'historians' have the South as the Winners" Abolishinist Saturday #49

No the won't cast the South as winners SocialDemocrat61 Sunday #50