General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)An open letter to Grammarly and other plagiarists, thieves and slop merchants (writer/critic/reporter Maureen Ryan) [View all]
She originally posted this March 10. I saw it today only because she reposted it with a Bluesky thread I'll copy below this excerpt from the open letter.
Wikipedia page on Maureen Ryan: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maureen_Ryan
And if you don't already know why writers are mad at Grammarly, see this: https://www.democraticunderground.com/10143630840
The letter:
https://www.moryan.com/an-open-letter-to-grammarly-and-other-plagiarists-thieves-and-slop-merchants/
You should be ashamed of where you work. Not just Grammarly or Superhuman or whatever comically dumb name you come up with next. Almost everyone running tech firms, most people in positions of responsibility, pretty much every C-suite type congrats, youre all making the world a worse place. People used to be excited about tech, now they dread what data you're going to steal next, they dread what violation of privacy or the environment will turn up next. There are people in tech who want to do good, but theyre consistently outvoted or stampeded by selfish hucksters and thieves. What the vast majority of those with power are doing or enabling is shamefully disrespectful and destructive. Everyone hyping and shilling for all this? You shouldnt be proud of making people dumber or stealing from people. Because LLMs and the whole AI hype machine its just idiocy, plagiarism, greed and theft on a grand scale.
These plagiarism machines simply regurgitate what has been fed into them. They are not capable of true art, real creativity, the kind of structure, nuance and depth that are the hallmarks of worthy acts of creativity. These slop machines are wrong a lot of the time, they encourage people to do terrible things, and they are simply bad for the world. I feel sad for anyone who uses them, because theyre degrading the human condition the ability to know and care and understand. All this theft, stupidity and degradation is not only bad and harmful it's unnecessary.
Because actual writers and artists and creative folks are right here! All we want is baseline respect and reasonable compensation. But the snake-oil salespeople pushing these hallucinating plagiarism machines on the rest of us think any compensation is too much! The executives ruining human discourse and the planet they must be lavishly paid. Actual creators we get exactly nothing. No money, no respect, no consent.
-snippjng a short paragraph saying FU to the AI companies-
You are wrecking the environment so that terrible people who make bad decisions can be enriched. You are destroying entire fields of creativity so that unsuspecting people can get bad information and advice from inaccurate, dumbly predictive slop machines. You are degrading the human condition. You are making the world a worse place.
-snip-
Amen.
Much more at the link above. Please read all of it - it's a great and very righteous rant.
Her thread today on Bluesky:
Props to Nilay for doing this work. Also posting this again, because Grammarly & so many companies & LLM-pilled techies built whole business models around ignoring consent & stealing shit & I don't like it. Grammarly stopped Expert Review but the gross mindsets remain www.moryan.com/an-open-lett...
— Mo Ryan (@moryan.bsky.social) 2026-03-23T14:25:15.603Z
Tech when I was a Young: "We're going to connect all of us to a ton of cool communities & info & games & music & hobbies & it's gonna be awesome"
— Mo Ryan (@moryan.bsky.social) 2026-03-23T14:32:29.991Z
Tech now: "We're going to steal your shit & kill every creative profession & surveil you & help the police state & YOU HAD BETTER LIKE IT you dumb poors"
Also a thing I think about a lot is the culture at these companies where the entire business model is built around ignoring, circumventing or minimizing consent. Gleefully so. Not that tech had the best rep for company cultures before, but whew. Now I worry about the industry's workers even more.
— Mo Ryan (@moryan.bsky.social) 2026-03-23T14:34:04.799Z
Will add, there are great people in tech. Like there are great people in Hollywood, truly awesome people. And I'm sorry way too many of them work for arrogant chodes who only care about lining their pockets and care zero about making the world or their industries worse.
— Mo Ryan (@moryan.bsky.social) 2026-03-23T14:36:01.153Z
If someone broke into a CEOâs house and trashed the house and took all their valuables, all that breaker-in would have to do is say, âI under delivered for you and you can opt out of future thefts, SORRY I tried to do you a *favor*â â yes, thatâs how the world works and itâs actually great! ðð»
— Mo Ryan (@moryan.bsky.social) 2026-03-23T16:20:42.804Z