General Discussion

highplainsdem

(60,945 posts)

37. Not at all the same thing. Using genAI is more like hiring someone else to do the work for you and

Wed Feb 11, 2026, 10:56 AM

Yesterday

pretending you did it because you gave them some instructions.

And they're completely unethical tools trained on stolen intellectual property.

Unless some genAI user is completely unaware of the IP theft - unlikely given all the news about it for years - they're acting unethically using genAI, showing contempt for the millions of people whose IP was stolen so people who don't have that knowledge or skill or creativity can pretend they do.

Click here to purchase valentine hearts!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

5 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

CaptainTruth Wild blueberry Wednesdays SheltieLover Piasladic

159 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

AI: Something Big Is Happening [View all] LiberalArkie Yesterday OP

Skynet becomes self-aware. sop Yesterday #1

Yep. OldBaldy1701E Yesterday #43

I'm not very tech-y at all so Alliepoo Yesterday #70

Yeah, I have a WIFI camera here as well. OldBaldy1701E Yesterday #97

Sounds like my house, too DFW Yesterday #75

I have been involved with IT. OldBaldy1701E Yesterday #98

The closest I came was allowing Alexa to turn off lights when requested mdbl Yesterday #92

Applause. (n/t) OldBaldy1701E Yesterday #99

1984... The film, "Electric Dreams"... ultralite001 Yesterday #94

I vaguely remember that film! (n/t) OldBaldy1701E Yesterday #101

🤣🤣🤣 ultralite001 15 hrs ago #146

That's what I think every time I see an article about AI FoxNewsSucks Yesterday #79

The science fiction of our younger years has spent the subsequent years becoming reality.... Jack Valentino 16 hrs ago #144

Wow! Kid Berwyn Yesterday #2

I am waiting on the MRI and CTSCAN data to actually get implemented into AI LiberalArkie Yesterday #4

A Miracle Kid Berwyn Yesterday #15

Freakononics on NPR ran a amall series in this ending yesterday. mahina Yesterday #45

One problem with CT/MRI scans Old Crank Yesterday #53

But not in the developed world where CT scans cost less than $100 LiberalArkie Yesterday #59

That reminds me of Star Trek. pandr32 Yesterday #55

Wait until a physics AI develops faster than light drives and fusion power and better is developed LiberalArkie Yesterday #62

Hopeful! pandr32 Yesterday #65

Sooner of later the U.S. will join the rest of the world in recognizing that the citizens are its income source and LiberalArkie Yesterday #68

Who needs people? PatSeg Yesterday #5

The Universe Kid Berwyn Yesterday #16

That's it in a nutshell. Thanks. TheRickles Yesterday #40

The only safe jobs are barbers and morticians Renew Deal Yesterday #9

Truly! Not to argue... Kid Berwyn Yesterday #23

Ditto! True Dough 17 hrs ago #130

That article is mostly marketing hype and not even close to reality. tinrobot 16 hrs ago #142

Huh, the CEO of an AI company tells me I need to adopt AI? Never would have guessed. Anyone who's familiar with WhiskeyGrinder Yesterday #3

He was also urging people on X to invest in AI companies as the best way to survive. One of the highplainsdem Yesterday #10

yeah he's been involved with a few shady investment schemes iirc WhiskeyGrinder Yesterday #11

Pfffft Prairie Gates Yesterday #6

A heart for that Easterncedar Yesterday #7

Anyone that thinks AI is a fad is badly mistaken Renew Deal Yesterday #8

I think most people are rightfully extremely concerned what this means for jobs (among other things) but mostly jobs themaguffin Yesterday #12

Not a fad. AI is the devil. Scrivener7 Yesterday #13

According to this guy, here's what you should do about the upcoming AI apocalypse... EarlG Yesterday #14

Thank you. You can tell this is just a sales pitch. Oneironaut Yesterday #38

Won't reach 100% perfectionl Old Crank Yesterday #63

"Programmers" don't just write code, though. Oneironaut Yesterday #76

Did you read the part where the newest AI debugs the code as well? scipan Yesterday #93

Tbh, I'll believe it when I see it. Oneironaut Yesterday #100

You are right to be skeptical. Also, see highplainsdem's post right above yours scipan 2 hrs ago #150

Matt Shumer, who wrote that hype, is well known for hype, has been accused of fraud, and has an highplainsdem 17 hrs ago #125

Oh. Thanks. He is not to be trusted to tell the truth. nt scipan 2 hrs ago #149

News articles that are actually shady sales pitches have been around since newspapers started. Crowman2009 Yesterday #48

The guy who wrote that advises people to buy AI company stock so they won't need jobs. highplainsdem Yesterday #61

As if people have enough money or will earn enough dividends to live on. Crowman2009 Yesterday #78

Vernon Vinge wrote the Singularity about ever evolving AI Swede Yesterday #17

Using it all the time now, it's incredible Johnny2X2X Yesterday #18

Imagine the outcry when painters (artists) started using pre-prepared paints instead of creating their own when creating LiberalArkie Yesterday #21

Good way to look at it Johnny2X2X Yesterday #24

YES popsdenver Yesterday #60

Not at all the same thing. Using genAI is more like hiring someone else to do the work for you and highplainsdem Yesterday #37

Absolutely! SheltieLover Yesterday #74

So you think people should quit their jobs? Johnny2X2X Yesterday #83

I've mentioned in a number of posts about how unethical voluntary use of genAI is that I know some highplainsdem 1 hr ago #151

But God forbid we should be able to use non-HP toner ink, or fix a tractor or combine we already paid for! hatrack 17 hrs ago #140

It will be a wonderful world... hunter Yesterday #26

This guy is full of shit. hunter Yesterday #19

Well stated. GreenWave Yesterday #33

AI is not the "Devil" justaprogressive Yesterday #20

We had no problem when the pencil was created and humans stopped using charcoal. LiberalArkie Yesterday #22

My nearly 60 years in IT says this is different. justaprogressive Yesterday #25

I am old enough to remember when the languages come out (C, Fortran etc) and writing in Assembler was being looked LiberalArkie Yesterday #28

Computers Johnny2X2X Yesterday #30

I think it might really be great when the AI's can create a modern processing structure that can replace the LiberalArkie Yesterday #35

It really will be a sea of new and more useful features for things we already use Johnny2X2X Yesterday #39

Again, not at all the same thing. See reply 37. highplainsdem Yesterday #57

Or advancing from whale oil to fossil fuels. Torchlight 32 min ago #155

Holy cadookalas! cachukis Yesterday #27

Anti-AI Crusaders should think about redirecting their energies to UBI TheProle Yesterday #29

And one more reason why the US needs to change to universal healthcare, area51 Yesterday #91

This gulliver 35 min ago #154

Is it time for this , again ? dweller Yesterday #31

How long before some idiot hands over control of the BIG RED BUTTON to AI? Ferrets are Cool Yesterday #32

About minus one year. usonian Yesterday #51

If nobody has a job... Happy Hoosier Yesterday #34

Sorry, but, this is vastly overestimating the capabilities of AI. Oneironaut Yesterday #36

It's definitely improving rapidly. Lucky Luciano Yesterday #46

There's no point in trying to fight it? Wrong. There's every reason to fight it, for our freedom from highplainsdem Yesterday #69

It's not just to misrepresent one's own intellect. A lot of use cases are pretty mundane. Lucky Luciano Yesterday #80

I'm sorry... hunter Yesterday #90

Your life sounds sad and woesome. nt Tommy Carcetti 19 hrs ago #115

?? Lucky Luciano 18 hrs ago #117

Whenever new AI models are revealed, there's always trememdous hype about how amazing they are, highplainsdem Yesterday #73

thanks . by your command. AllaN01Bear Yesterday #41

What about the AI Agent platform that has been created and is AI only yobrault1 Yesterday #42

That's already been exposed as mostly fraud, with humans having written the posts getting the highplainsdem Yesterday #66

Next step Mosby Yesterday #44

Can A I replace dweller Yesterday #47

Corporate executives are an AI job replacement I would approve of! Crowman2009 Yesterday #50

I have been using the paid versions of GPT and Claude for a while now Disaffected Yesterday #49

Agree Johnny2X2X 23 hrs ago #107

Yes, I've had it do some VBA/Excel as well. Disaffected 22 hrs ago #108

I, for one, am eager for the day when... WestMichRad Yesterday #52

Bernie Sanders nails it, as usual. usonian Yesterday #54

Think of all the scribes that were put out of work when Gutenberg invented the printing press. LiberalArkie Yesterday #56

Gutenberg, Edison and whoever did not set out to destroy an entire class and population usonian Yesterday #67

In my Petro space, we are eliminating jobs Melon Yesterday #58

What kind of world do you want to retire into? hunter Yesterday #86

Technology can't go backwards Melon Yesterday #95

We sound old ThreeNoSeep Yesterday #64

The literal #1 job growth opportunity for the next 10 years? Moostache Yesterday #71

Worthy of an OP usonian Yesterday #77

Yours is an impressive, thoughtful response. yonder 23 hrs ago #105

Not willing to give up our fresh water for this Wild blueberry Yesterday #72

I never understood the water usage. LiberalArkie Yesterday #82

Many data centers use evaporative cooling. hunter 22 hrs ago #109

My entire life has been ever-more-rapid technological change Soul_of_Wit Yesterday #81

I did it at 65. I was just really tired and inside felt that I was dying. LiberalArkie Yesterday #84

I've been in IT for over 30 years angrychair Yesterday #85

It is already replacing entry-level jobs Soul_of_Wit Yesterday #88

No business has shown an ROI angrychair Yesterday #96

The stats TheProle 21 hrs ago #112

The stats are awful angrychair 19 hrs ago #116

Ed Zitron has done a great job explaining this insane AI bubble. highplainsdem 17 hrs ago #137

According to a Wharton study, 75% of enterprises "report positive return on investment." Renew Deal 18 hrs ago #121

Mollick is one of the biggest shills for the AI industry. highplainsdem 18 hrs ago #122

There's a lot of attacking the messenger in this thread Renew Deal 17 hrs ago #126

The messenger in the OP, Matt Shumer, is already known for both hype and fraud. highplainsdem 17 hrs ago #132

What do you think happens in the collapse? Renew Deal 17 hrs ago #133

lets see lapfog_1 16 hrs ago #145

MIT report: 95% of generative AI pilots at companies are failing highplainsdem 17 hrs ago #124

Those are pilots Renew Deal 17 hrs ago #128

By that standard, Trump was doing things right with all his business failures. highplainsdem 17 hrs ago #134

Those were not pilots Renew Deal 17 hrs ago #135

I'd have to read the study...but... Lucky Luciano 3 hrs ago #147

This is not relevant to the comment you replied to Soul_of_Wit 2 hrs ago #148

Reading the comments to this thread is an interesting mix of skepticism, optimism, fear, and... Ol Janx Spirit Yesterday #87

Oh, Please DarthDem Yesterday #89

7x8 equals 56 usedtobedemgurl Yesterday #102

A very plausible timeline of the next couple of years: LudwigPastorius 23 hrs ago #103

Ohh Hell LiberalArkie 22 hrs ago #111

Breakin' 2: Electric Boogaloo Torchlight 23 hrs ago #104

Visual representation RoseTrellis 23 hrs ago #106

Can We Use AI To Help Rid Us Of Tr**p?....nt9 global1 22 hrs ago #110

Matt Shumer is known for overhyping and has been accused of fraud. See this: highplainsdem 20 hrs ago #113

Bank on this: Basic income, universal healthcare, inheritance for all, and... pat_k 19 hrs ago #114

No way that's going to happen with the AI bros and the Trump regime. And their intent is to rig highplainsdem 18 hrs ago #118

30 to 40 million displaced white collar workers would make a hell of a noise. pat_k 18 hrs ago #123

I think that only becomes possible after significant poverty and destruction Renew Deal 17 hrs ago #131

If the predicted 50% of the 70 million or so white collar/professionals/knowledge workers lose their jobs. pat_k 17 hrs ago #139

LOL!!! Matt Shumer's company offers AI generators for "team member praise" and heartfelt sympathy highplainsdem 18 hrs ago #119

LOL! Shumer needed AI to help him write that piece! Talk about someone being AI-dependent...but highplainsdem 18 hrs ago #120

LiberalArkie, did you bother to find out ANYTHING about Matt Shumer's background before you posted this? highplainsdem 17 hrs ago #127

This message was self-deleted by its author sakabatou 17 hrs ago #129

AI slop using tools trained on stolen intellectual property. highplainsdem 17 hrs ago #136

Tell that to the illustrator Miyu, plus Andrew Holmes & Cosmoz Productions sakabatou 17 hrs ago #138

It's a chatbot with a very annoying voice. And they won't reveal the training data, which suggests very highplainsdem 17 hrs ago #141

Reddit thread on Shumer's hypefest: highplainsdem 16 hrs ago #143

Reddit thread & YouTube video on why Shumer was accused of fraud in 2024: highplainsdem 1 hr ago #152

Things are getting real Johnny2X2X 1 hr ago #153

AI is getting really hyped as they try to sustain their AI bubble. Microsoft pushing AI has met with a highplainsdem 2 min ago #159

This is why the Epstein-ICE melodramas are so terrible for us all gulliver 20 min ago #156

I fear the ship has sailed with the 2024 elections Johnny2X2X 17 min ago #157

It is an opening for Dems gulliver 9 min ago #158