General Discussion

Prairie Gates

(7,581 posts)

20. You cannot be "held for questioning" - it's not a thing at all

Tue Feb 10, 2026, 11:05 PM

17 hrs ago

You are either under arrest or you are not. You cannot be forced to answer questions. That's the first thing: "You have the right to remain silent..."

Click here to purchase valentine hearts!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

dweller

43 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

"detained for questioning" in Guthrie case? [View all] Jersey Devil 18 hrs ago OP

thank you Skittles 18 hrs ago #1

Me too. n/t iluvtennis 16 hrs ago #31

Are the news sources getting this info from Kash Patel? Greywing 18 hrs ago #2

Yeah, ol Cash crossed my mind, too. Cha 17 hrs ago #4

Bingo. The Keystone Cops at work! In an autocratic KPN 15 hrs ago #33

Mahalo, Jersey Devil.. Cha 17 hrs ago #3

Saw it Rebl2 17 hrs ago #5

Let's not pretend like everything always goes by the book. RockRaven 17 hrs ago #6

Sure, but there must be an arrest Jersey Devil 17 hrs ago #13

Did they send ICE? It would be on par for this FBI & WH to totally fuck over Maru Kitteh 17 hrs ago #7

Could be. ShazzieB 15 hrs ago #32

It's Kash's Law! CanonRay 17 hrs ago #8

I call bullshit montanacowboy 17 hrs ago #9

NBC interrupted Olympics coverage TommyT139 17 hrs ago #12

Something about this news report is screwy Jersey Devil 17 hrs ago #14

Absolutely! KPN 15 hrs ago #34

Is it the case TommyT139 17 hrs ago #10

That's a TV show 48 hours gab13by13 17 hrs ago #16

See comment 22. "Quarles exception" TommyT139 16 hrs ago #23

You can't detain someone simply because a life is at risk Jersey Devil 16 hrs ago #29

There is no provision to hold someone to answer questions Jersey Devil 17 hrs ago #17

See comment 22: "Quarles exception" TommyT139 16 hrs ago #24

You cannot be "held for questioning" - it's not a thing at all Prairie Gates 17 hrs ago #20

Talking head on MSNBC TommyT139 16 hrs ago #22

Quarles is an exception to Miranda warnings, not the requirement to arrest someone for questioning Jersey Devil 16 hrs ago #27

That's not what I said TommyT139 16 hrs ago #28

Hopefully this is a good sign Johnny2X2X 17 hrs ago #11

Could you explain what we're supposed to be looking at on your link? Sogo 16 hrs ago #25

meh. i was once 'detained' but not arrested by chgo cops. mopinko 17 hrs ago #15

You were arrested Jersey Devil 17 hrs ago #18

oh i know. i was either arrested or illegally detained. but they insisted i wasnt under arrest. mopinko 17 hrs ago #19

Spunds like they made something up to cover their asses Jersey Devil 16 hrs ago #30

Why would you conflate the ability to sue or the right to a remedy with "cannot be detained without arrest" Ilikepurple 15 hrs ago #35

i talked to a lawyer. mopinko 14 hrs ago #36

Obviously unlawful detention exists. If there was no such thing, we wouldn't need its associated due process right. Ilikepurple 16 hrs ago #21

Terry stop? Jersey Devil 14 hrs ago #37

They're probably detaining him because he's not a citizen. Frasier Balzov 16 hrs ago #26

That could be the answer Jersey Devil 14 hrs ago #38

I think this is cartel activity Melon 14 hrs ago #39

Police release man detained in connection to Nancy Guthrie disappearance muriel_volestrangler 11 hrs ago #40

Totally on brand Kash, you latex knob. Maru Kitteh 3 hrs ago #43

So you're suggesting that Kash et al malaise 10 hrs ago #41

I did not know this cally 9 hrs ago #42