Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

gfarber

(200 posts)
6. The Generous Mirage
Thu Dec 4, 2025, 01:44 PM
Dec 4


There once was a nation in thrall
To illusions both shiny and tall.
A billionaire’s gift
Gave the markets a lift,
But gave kids next to nothing at all.

The Dells dropped a fortune with flair,
And the headlines applauded the pair.
Yet the act, if unmasked,
Shows the public been tasked
With pretending that crumbs are fair share.

The state could have bolstered the poor,
Built schools, raised the wages, and more.
But instead it contrived
A scheme pre-survived
By the markets that ate them before.

Two-fifty sounds kind at first glance,
But it’s really a market romance.
Kids are drafted to play
In the Wall Street ballet—
Unwilling, unarmed for the dance.

Now welfare’s no longer a right;
It’s a billionaire’s game-day delight.
If they choose to bestow
A small charitable glow,
We must praise them from morning ‘til night.

First you starve all the systems to bone,
Till the public is weary and prone.
Then a rich man appears,
Wins applause, wins careers,
For a drop from the wealth he’s alone.

Each cheer for the savior’s “good deed”
Hides the truth of a deeper misdeed:
That the state’s stepped aside,
Let the markets preside,
And called it fulfilling a need.

So folks look at the gift and say “Hey—
It might help the kids… maybe… someday.”
But they don’t dare admit
What’s at heart of the pit:
That the country has walked away.
Key paragraph to me NewHendoLib Dec 4 #1
It's the equivalent of an office pizza party instead of a raise EdmondDantes_ Dec 4 #2
With nasty burps after. erronis Dec 4 #4
no toppings, extra crust, cold. twodogsbarking Dec 4 #17
I couldn't agree more. Diamond_Dog Dec 4 #3
Definitely! OldBaldy1701E Dec 4 #7
The phrase... GiqueCee Dec 4 #10
The irony is that at the end of her life, mwmisses4289 Dec 5 #46
Yup... GiqueCee Dec 5 #48
Agree, the is a pretty good visual explanation... walkingman Dec 4 #5
When I saw Susan Dell I thought she was BigmanPigman Dec 4 #24
She is ugly because of the person she is Bluestocking Dec 4 #29
The Generous Mirage gfarber Dec 4 #6
Excellent one today! Perfectly captures the fairy-tale nature. erronis Dec 4 #21
...... 70sEraVet Dec 4 #36
You've done it again, gfarber! calimary Dec 5 #43
Yes. OldBaldy1701E Dec 4 #8
Apologies for the crappy formatting. (n/t) OldBaldy1701E Dec 4 #31
It's crumbs, while billionaires lap up billions in tax breaks. SunSeeker Dec 4 #9
I read estimate that Peter Thiel has $5 billion in Roth accounts that grew from a few thousand dollars lostnfound Dec 5 #45
Not hard to believe. Roth does provide a potentially enormousloophole. And if you happen to be lucky enough, KPN Dec 5 #49
I agree. TommieMommy Dec 4 #11
The Dells are big supporters of Greg Abbott and have bronxiteforever Dec 4 #12
K&R Solly Mack Dec 4 #13
My thoughts exactly popsdenver Dec 4 #14
I completely agree. It's another shot at Social Security underpants Dec 4 #26
I watched this performance on the "news" mountain grammy Dec 4 #15
And, does anyone think these accounts won't be subject to... Ol Janx Spirit Dec 4 #16
"It's a corporate heist dressed up as philanthropy, and America is too exhausted or too desperate to notice." DeeDeeNY Dec 4 #18
When I saw this story yesterday, I thought "Why do they have $6.25 B. They need to be taxed more." ... aggiesal Dec 4 #19
Yes, that line jumped out for me too. They had $6.5 billion to just "drop". txwhitedove Dec 5 #47
Anand Giridharadas talked about this sort of empty largesse Pinback Dec 4 #20
Anand Giridharadas - I can't get enough of his analysis. yellow dahlia Dec 4 #41
As always, Republicans only act generous when they are the beneficiaries of the generosity. rickford66 Dec 4 #22
The beginning of the end of DownriverDem Dec 4 #23
Yes. More of the shell game hidden behind smoke and mirrors. yellow dahlia Dec 4 #40
Plus they get a nice tax break nt LNM Dec 4 #25
Didn't even have to understand it, the names alone tell you ita a grift. Srkdqltr Dec 4 #27
The last paragraph underpants Dec 4 #28
My work computer is a Dell laptop Bluestocking Dec 4 #30
Their vision for America is Charles Dickens' England MuirHero Dec 4 #32
Kick dalton99a Dec 4 #33
K&R. Bookmarked. Thanks. c-rational Dec 4 #34
Capitalism is the problem. BlueTsunami2018 Dec 4 #35
Yeah... what if in two decades, there's been a nuclear war... Justice matters. Dec 4 #37
I have no mouth and I must scream. (Harlan Ellison) chouchou Dec 4 #38
What a smart piece! yellow dahlia Dec 4 #39
K&R jfz9580m Dec 4 #42
Thanks for this malaise Dec 5 #44
Pretty sure rightwing evangelical ministers across the country will be celebrating the virtues of the Dells KPN Dec 5 #50
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Biggest Heist in Amer...»Reply #6