Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

Kid Berwyn

(22,487 posts)
Thu Dec 4, 2025, 12:17 PM Yesterday

The Biggest Heist in America Is Being Sold as a Gift to Children [View all]



The Biggest Heist in America Is Being Sold as a Gift to Children

by Sean Carlton
Counterpunch.org, December 4, 2025

America loves a good illusion. It loves the performance of generosity from people who built their fortunes on systems that leave everyone else scrambling. That’s why the country is celebrating Michael and Susan Dell dropping $6.25 billion into “Trump Accounts.” Twenty-five million kids will get $250 each in a special savings account that they can’t touch for almost two decades. It sounds like generosity. It plays like hope. It sells like opportunity. But it isn’t any of that. It’s a corporate heist dressed up as philanthropy, and America is too exhausted or too desperate to notice.

The Dell announcement isn’t about helping children. It’s about normalizing a future where the only people who can fix failing systems are the same corporations and billionaires who helped break them. The government could’ve built real support for families. It could’ve raised wages, stabilized housing, funded public education, or given parents actual resources instead of symbolic ones. Instead it built a program where kids get locked into market accounts, and then it waited for a billionaire to swoop in and finish the job. That isn’t policy. It isn’t progress. It’s the privatization of the public good.

A one-time $250 deposit isn’t lifting anyone out of anything. At best it turns children into unwilling investors in a financial system that’s already eaten their parents alive. At worst it shifts the entire idea of welfare into something that only functions if wealthy people feel like playing savior for a news cycle. This isn’t social support. It’s a handshake between private wealth and a government that no longer knows how to govern unless the market approves.

The trick here is simple and old. You starve the public systems until they’re so weak that anything looks like relief. Then you let a billionaire deliver a drop of water and call it a miracle. Americans have been trained to applaud the spectacle. They forget to ask why one of the richest men in the country gets to decide how twenty-five million children experience their first introduction to money. They forget to ask why the richest people get public praise for giving back pennies compared to what they extract. They forget to ask why children need investment accounts instead of stable housing, food, medical care, and schools that aren’t falling apart.

The applause is the point. When billionaires are cast as heroes, no one has to admit that the system has collapsed so thoroughly that private charity is now doing the work of the state. This is how the social contract dies without anyone calling it what it is. People look at the $250 and say at least it’s something. They say maybe it’ll grow. They say maybe it’ll help someday. They don’t say what’s obvious. They don’t say the quiet part. They don’t say that America now expects the financial markets to raise children because the country has decided it won’t.

Continues…

https://www.counterpunch.org/2025/12/04/the-biggest-heist-in-america-is-being-sold-as-a-gift-to-children/

PS: “The illusion of freedom will continue as long as it's profitable to continue the illusion. At the point where the illusion becomes too expensive to maintain, they will just take down the scenery, they will pull back the curtains, they will move the tables and chairs out of the way and you will see the brick wall at the back of the theater.” — Frank Zappa
50 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Key paragraph to me NewHendoLib Yesterday #1
It's the equivalent of an office pizza party instead of a raise EdmondDantes_ Yesterday #2
With nasty burps after. erronis Yesterday #4
no toppings, extra crust, cold. twodogsbarking Yesterday #17
I couldn't agree more. Diamond_Dog Yesterday #3
Definitely! OldBaldy1701E Yesterday #7
The phrase... GiqueCee Yesterday #10
The irony is that at the end of her life, mwmisses4289 6 hrs ago #46
Yup... GiqueCee 4 hrs ago #48
Agree, the is a pretty good visual explanation... walkingman Yesterday #5
When I saw Susan Dell I thought she was BigmanPigman 22 hrs ago #24
She is ugly because of the person she is Bluestocking 21 hrs ago #29
The Generous Mirage gfarber Yesterday #6
Excellent one today! Perfectly captures the fairy-tale nature. erronis 23 hrs ago #21
...... 70sEraVet 20 hrs ago #36
You've done it again, gfarber! calimary 12 hrs ago #43
Yes. OldBaldy1701E Yesterday #8
Apologies for the crappy formatting. (n/t) OldBaldy1701E 21 hrs ago #31
It's crumbs, while billionaires lap up billions in tax breaks. SunSeeker Yesterday #9
I read estimate that Peter Thiel has $5 billion in Roth accounts that grew from a few thousand dollars lostnfound 8 hrs ago #45
Not hard to believe. Roth does provide a potentially enormousloophole. And if you happen to be lucky enough, KPN 4 hrs ago #49
I agree. TommieMommy Yesterday #11
The Dells are big supporters of Greg Abbott and have bronxiteforever Yesterday #12
K&R Solly Mack Yesterday #13
My thoughts exactly popsdenver Yesterday #14
I completely agree. It's another shot at Social Security underpants 22 hrs ago #26
I watched this performance on the "news" mountain grammy Yesterday #15
And, does anyone think these accounts won't be subject to... Ol Janx Spirit Yesterday #16
"It's a corporate heist dressed up as philanthropy, and America is too exhausted or too desperate to notice." DeeDeeNY Yesterday #18
When I saw this story yesterday, I thought "Why do they have $6.25 B. They need to be taxed more." ... aggiesal Yesterday #19
Yes, that line jumped out for me too. They had $6.5 billion to just "drop". txwhitedove 5 hrs ago #47
Anand Giridharadas talked about this sort of empty largesse Pinback Yesterday #20
Anand Giridharadas - I can't get enough of his analysis. yellow dahlia 19 hrs ago #41
As always, Republicans only act generous when they are the beneficiaries of the generosity. rickford66 23 hrs ago #22
The beginning of the end of DownriverDem 22 hrs ago #23
Yes. More of the shell game hidden behind smoke and mirrors. yellow dahlia 19 hrs ago #40
Plus they get a nice tax break nt LNM 22 hrs ago #25
Didn't even have to understand it, the names alone tell you ita a grift. Srkdqltr 22 hrs ago #27
The last paragraph underpants 22 hrs ago #28
My work computer is a Dell laptop Bluestocking 21 hrs ago #30
Their vision for America is Charles Dickens' England MuirHero 21 hrs ago #32
Kick dalton99a 21 hrs ago #33
K&R. Bookmarked. Thanks. c-rational 21 hrs ago #34
Capitalism is the problem. BlueTsunami2018 20 hrs ago #35
Yeah... what if in two decades, there's been a nuclear war... Justice matters. 19 hrs ago #37
I have no mouth and I must scream. (Harlan Ellison) chouchou 19 hrs ago #38
What a smart piece! yellow dahlia 19 hrs ago #39
K&R jfz9580m 18 hrs ago #42
Thanks for this malaise 9 hrs ago #44
Pretty sure rightwing evangelical ministers across the country will be celebrating the virtues of the Dells KPN 4 hrs ago #50
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Biggest Heist in Amer...