General Discussion

Boo1

(91 posts)

12. The paper and assignment are linked in the article

Sun Nov 30, 2025, 07:35 PM

Sunday

Last edited Mon Dec 1, 2025, 02:00 AM - Edit history (2)

and I have to say, I think the student has a legit gripe.

Their paper isnt good, and certainly does all of the things that the grader noted. However, the assignment doesn't really say that those things are a reason to lose points. The assignment is a reaction paper to an article that is assigned reading. It offers ideas who how to approach it, the first being

"A discussion of why you feel the topic is important and worthy of study (or not)."

And I think this paper certainly meets that offering. There is even a rubric attached to the assignment, and I fail to see how each one wasn't atleast partially met.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

9 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Ms. Toad mr715 Blasphemer SomewhereInTheMiddle Jim__PatSeg Abolishinist scipan Iris

42 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

OU student claims bad grade is an attack on her faith [View all] marmar Sunday OP

Teeing up for the Supreme Court. 50 Shades Of Blue Sunday #1

Sounds a bit like a wingnut operation. Turbineguy Sunday #2

Oh give me a f*cking break. Dave Bowman Sunday #3

"Lacked any academic rigor" BOSSHOG Sunday #4

Seriously....... i feel like a sucker for making an honest living when I could have just been Riley Gaines Takket Sunday #19

Well, today they have the supreme court they love, so bluestarone Sunday #5

White "Christian" Nationalist bullshit Nigrum Cattus Sunday #6

Beyonce disagrees with her conclusions. intheflow Sunday #7

"...biblical teachings to argue for traditional gender roles..." J_William_Ryan Sunday #8

Of course, it's Biblical Oklahoma. sinkingfeeling Sunday #9

A zero? That does sound a bit extreme. Jim__ Sunday #10

The paper and assignment are linked in the article Boo1 Sunday #12

Thanks, I hadn't seen those links. Jim__ Sunday #15

I agree. The assignment gave the students a lot of flexibility. This is a failure of the instructor & the grader... Blasphemer Monday #24

Have you taught college ever? róisín_dubh Monday #41

I'm guessing, the "because God says so" argument didn't meet the critical thinking threshold Raven123 Monday #31

I had the same thoughts. The grade feels reactive. Iris Yesterday #42

This is Oklahoma, so... Diraven Sunday #11

Samantha might want to look into a transfer to cloudbase Sunday #13

This message was self-deleted by its author valleyrogue Sunday #14

Doesn't know the Bible enough to reference specific scripture.... Sounds like a Trump Christian. Norrrm Sunday #16

Sounds like the lead up to a GiveSendGo/GoFundMe scam. flvegan Sunday #17

I don't know about that. Iggo Sunday #18

kind of hard to use religion as an excuse when you don't even quote scripture Takket Sunday #20

This is (should be) a private matter between the student and the professor. Ms. Toad Sunday #21

Two extremists collide. yardwork Sunday #22

It won't get that far. Ms. Toad Monday #26

Agree with everything you said Boo1 Monday #29

I hope you're right but these are weird times. yardwork Monday #35

The action taken by the school (suspending the graduate student's teaching role). Ms. Toad Monday #38

This Husband-of-a-Professor appreciates your perspective. Drum Sunday #23

In her essay she said: 'Gender roles and tendencies should not be considered "stereotypes". 'Women naturally want to do BlueWaveNeverEnd Monday #28

I took a "Bible as Literature" class once... hunter Monday #25

Yeah, religious studies is not proselytizing iemanja Monday #39

This IS from a part of our nation that tried to legislate the value of Pi lapfog_1 Monday #27

They always play the role of the persecuted. SamKnause Monday #30

Hun, if you feel that strongly about Biblical traditional gender roles, then why are you in college? tanyev Monday #32

One wonders why she took a psychology course. yardwork Monday #36

Turning Point had a huge rally there recently. redstatebluegirl Monday #33

As a former "graduate assistant paper grader", I would not have given a grade of zero. JustABozoOnThisBus Monday #34

Christian Taliban youth core. nt Hotler Monday #37

There are ways to study Christianity iemanja Monday #40