General Discussion

JonAndKatePlusABird

(363 posts)

40. Hyperbole much?

Reply to Wiz Imp (Reply #24)

Sun Nov 30, 2025, 09:26 AM

Sunday

Really compelling analysis of his analysis…

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Celerity Autumn

57 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

An investor called $140,000 the new poverty line. Experts disagreed but said he had a point. [View all] Zorro Saturday OP

American Enterprise Institute has only one wing nilram Saturday #1

A fantasy snowybirdie Saturday #2

I would buy this sum is accurate (even low) if one desires to live in an expensive, desirable area AZJonnie Saturday #3

Why shouldn't a "lifestyle" include sports and 2 cars? leftstreet Saturday #5

I think that might be his point. yardwork Sunday #44

Ridiculous Greg_In_SF Saturday #4

When you start with a baseline of 40% dpibel Saturday #11

Well, then it Greg_In_SF Saturday #14

Well, feel free to trot out the figures dpibel Saturday #19

A map.... Greg_In_SF Sunday #32

Now you're just being obtuse dpibel Sunday #43

How dare you call me obtuse Greg_In_SF Sunday #55

DURec leftstreet Saturday #6

"It's laughable to put a poverty line far above the median income in the United States." mountain grammy Saturday #7

Yes, talk about circular logic! yardwork Sunday #45

Mr. Green's numbers sound about right. mwmisses4289 Saturday #8

"minimum rent in most areas is around $2000 a month" -Extremely wrong Wiz Imp Saturday #12

Be interesting to see how they came up with those numbers. mwmisses4289 Saturday #13

It's from the American Community Survey Wiz Imp Saturday #16

You'd have to limit the options to housing appropriate to a family of 4 EdmondDantes_ Saturday #17

I was responding to the claim that minimum rent was at leas $2000 Wiz Imp Saturday #23

That post mentioned families, and in the larger context of the thread EdmondDantes_ Sunday #49

✋ 🙄🫨😒🧱💤🚫🫷「 ✦ Bye ✦ 」 Wiz Imp Sunday #50

In my area in NC even a run-down unsafe apartment is more than $1,000. yardwork Sunday #46

Green's required net income: $118,009. The $136,500 is gross. For a family of 4. Celerity Saturday #26

That's another reason a lot of people Haggard Celine Sunday #33

That was the reason my wife worked part time until our daughter was old enough for elementary school NickB79 Sunday #41

Anyone hiring young people to six figures Johonny Sunday #42

Don't know national averages but a little perspective JT45242 Sunday #51

Several points here. First, "laughable to put a poverty line far above the median income" is itself laughable unblock Saturday #9

The basic definition of poverty is this: Wiz Imp Saturday #25

The observations have merit, even if the specific application of conclusion doesn't. unblock Sunday #31

I would think for most families of 4 it's enough to live on but very little disposable income for extras. Raftergirl Saturday #10

Good point Greg_In_SF Saturday #15

Big jump, no? dpibel Saturday #20

I see my Greg_In_SF Monday #56

LOL dpibel Monday #57

LOL!!! valleyrogue Saturday #18

But I believe you've missed the point dpibel Saturday #21

Residents making an annual income of up to $109,700 who are living in Marin, San Francisco, San Mateo, Santa Clara and Celerity Saturday #22

To be fair, we are insane Sympthsical Sunday #39

Michael Green is a moron. Wiz Imp Saturday #24

This is a very convincing argument dpibel Sunday #27

Disagree (after reading it fully) & the $136,500 figure is gross, his required net income: $118,009. For a family of 4. Celerity Sunday #30

Spot on! DFW Sunday #37

Hyperbole much? JonAndKatePlusABird Sunday #40

Depends where you live. OAITW r.2.0 Sunday #28

People with decent incomes and wealth live beyond their means JI7 Sunday #29

That seems a rather blanket statement, sorta like "every immigrant from India is a math genius" DFW Sunday #48

I wouldn't call it a "poverty" line, but the "living wage" line. Below that, government subsidies are necessary. nt Blasphemer Sunday #34

you lose more than you gain as you move up from very low income levels Celerity Sunday #36

+1 Really good article leftstreet Sunday #47

Depends on Location and Demographics DET Sunday #35

The reactions to this are so goddamn illuminating WhiskeyGrinder Sunday #38

While most of the posts in this thread have been about housing costs, PoindexterOglethorpe Sunday #52

Child care is the largest cost in the OP article's example. Larger than housing cost. Celerity Sunday #54

"It's laughable to put a poverty line far above the median income in the United States." Grins Sunday #53