Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mopinko

(73,004 posts)
18. for most ppl, their homes r their biggest investment.
Fri Aug 1, 2025, 10:58 PM
Aug 1

and u r completely wrong about who this benefits. when u talk about averages, it’s not actually helpful.
u cant buy anything in good condition in a big city for $250k, and that’s where the decent jobs r.
and it’s 1 time. most ppl in spendy houses didnt start there. they traded up a couple of times.

when we bought our home, my then hubs was not making a lot of money. 1 reason it has gained so much value is that we bought in a very diverse hood when that was not a cool thing to do.
that, and making many improvements over the yrs makes it worth twice what it wd b untouched. a lot of that was sweat. for about half the big improvements, we had to refi. we’ve put more into it than we paid for it. our family grew and the house had to stretch. not an uncommon story. no speculation, no maneuvering.

very few of the ppl who live on my block ever made big money. there’s a couple college profs, a former construction manager, but that’s about as high as it goes. most bought long ago, their homes r paid off, and they r counting on selling the big house they raised the kids in for their retirements.

and i dont think the big house munchers will end up w the homes around here. they grab up the bargains. the ugly houses, the foreclosures. if they’re looking for mcmansions, those arent here, either. no bnb’s even. just a working class hood, w good solid but mostly pretty humble homes.
but the going rate these days is getting into the $550-600k range. for a widow who’s lived her for 20-30 yrs, that will b a hit.

and again, b4 clinton, once in your life, you cd sell your primary residence and pay NO capital gain.
it was good policy. it benefited retirees, seniors who worked hard and played by the rules, and widows/divorcées. ppl who were the backbone of middle class neighborhoods.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Oh great, as if he wasn't already causing a recession Metaphorical Jul 31 #1
You seem to be misreading the proposal Ms. Toad Jul 31 #2
Thanks for this, MT. The detail of having to live in a house for two years... brush Aug 2 #26
Making it more lucrative for long time homeowners to sell would benefit anyone wanting to buy DBoon Jul 31 #3
I agree Dave says Aug 1 #10
you're assuming a couple. mopinko Aug 1 #14
Most people don't have much Dave says Aug 1 #16
for most ppl, their homes r their biggest investment. mopinko Aug 1 #18
Median house value is $410.8k Dave says Aug 2 #19
that's how it used to b. mopinko Jul 31 #4
Capital gains tops out at 20%, not 39% tinrobot Aug 1 #7
ty. i forgot about that. mopinko Aug 1 #11
The heirs wouldn't pay on capital gains Dave says Aug 2 #20
I support. We need turnover on the housing market Melon Aug 1 #5
It only matters if the gain exceeds $500/250k Dave says Aug 2 #21
That's not true. Any $250k house in in 2016 Melon Aug 2 #24
What's not true? Dave says Aug 2 #25
The lack of affordable housing has continued to moniss Aug 1 #6
Basically, this would give big tax breaks to rich people tinrobot Aug 1 #8
a cap is fine, but housing prices in a lot of places r well above that. mopinko Aug 1 #12
I agree, the limits were set in the Clinton era and never adjusted tinrobot Aug 1 #15
They weren't indexed but they were adjusted Dave says Aug 2 #22
I'm in a profession acutely aware of what would happen if this were to be implemented. W_HAMILTON Aug 1 #9
you're assuming they cd use it over and over. mopinko Aug 1 #13
Not correct Dave says Aug 2 #23
Can we please get these fucking idiots out of our government now? Initech Aug 1 #17
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Trump wants to 'unleash' ...»Reply #18