Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Bayard

(30,389 posts)
Thu May 28, 2026, 12:03 AM 11 hrs ago

NASA's Curiosity rover has found organic molecules on Mars that may be billions of years old

NASA's Curiosity rover has found organic molecules on Mars that may be billions of years old — and the scientists studying them are being careful about what they say next. Thirteen years after landing in Gale Crater, NASA's Curiosity rover has produced what may be its most significant scientific result to date.

Thirteen years after landing in Gale Crater, NASA’s Curiosity rover has produced what may be its most significant scientific result to date. In a paper published in Nature Communications in April 2026, researchers led by Amy Williams, an astrobiologist and professor of geological sciences at the University of Florida, reported the detection of more than 20 organic molecules in a single Martian rock sample — the most diverse collection ever found on the planet. Seven of the molecules had never been confirmed on Mars before.

The findings have generated substantial coverage, most of it accurate. Some of it has also required the scientists involved to do something that researchers in this field have learned to do carefully: explain, repeatedly and in precise terms, what the discovery does and does not mean.

The experiment at the centre of the April findings used a chemical called tetramethylammonium hydroxide, or TMAH — a solvent capable of breaking apart large organic molecules into smaller fragments that Curiosity’s onboard instruments can then identify. The rover carries only two cups of this chemical. The decision about where to use the first cup was not made lightly.

The chosen sample, drilled from a site the team named Mary Anning 3 — after the 19th-century British paleontologist who spent her career finding fossils others had overlooked — came from the Glen Torridon region of Gale Crater, an ancient clay-rich area that scientists believe once held standing water. The clay minerals there are known to preserve organic material over geological timescales. The sample itself is estimated to be approximately 3.5 billion years old.

“This experiment’s never been run before on another world,” Williams told AFP. The team had two chances to get it right. They used the first one here.

https://spacedaily.com/n-nasas-curiosity-rover-has-found-organic-molecules-on-mars-that-may-be-billions-of-years-old-and-the-scientists-studying-them-are-being-careful-about-what-they-say-next

This material may be lost forever because in Jan. 2026, the rethuglican Congress canceled Mars Sample Return program.
3 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
NASA's Curiosity rover has found organic molecules on Mars that may be billions of years old (Original Post) Bayard 11 hrs ago OP
Breakdown products -- the same products can come from many different sources. eppur_se_muova 11 hrs ago #1
Why would they cancel the program Figarosmom 8 hrs ago #2
It's so much more fun going somewhere you know nothing about! dickthegrouch 7 hrs ago #3

eppur_se_muova

(42,595 posts)
1. Breakdown products -- the same products can come from many different sources.
Thu May 28, 2026, 12:24 AM
11 hrs ago
What the TMAH dissolved and released included nitrogen-bearing organic compounds, sulfur-bearing molecules including benzothiophene — previously found in meteorites and asteroids — and a range of carbon-containing structures that, on Earth, are associated with the chemistry of living systems. Among them was a molecule structurally similar to precursors of DNA. The results were verified on Earth by exposing a piece of the Murchison meteorite, a well-studied 4-billion-year-old rock containing organic chemistry, to the same TMAH process. It produced similar breakdown products, including benzothiophene, lending confidence to the Martian readings.


I hope they're more convincing than benzothiophene. Heat almost any hydrocarbon with sulfur hot enough, and you'll get some benzothiphoene. It doesn't mean benzothiophene, or even the branched eight-carbon skeleton of benzothiophen, was present in the sample. It means there were enough carbon, hydrogen, and sulfur atoms that when you cooked them all up and allowed them to re-form into stable molecules, the very stable benzothiophen was some of what resulted. I hope people appreciate what very indirect evidence this is -- the same results could have come from an endless variety of starting points.

Seven of the molecules had never been confirmed on Mars before.


They still haven't. We have only confirmed that Mars contains materials that, forced to decompose and recombine, can form these materials. This is a completely separate question from whether these compounds were originally present, and they almost certainly weren't.

Scientists who search desperately for life where it's not known to exist sometimes seem to be on a religious crusade, and every sign from above only confirms their faith. Maybe someday they'll prove right in one particular instance, but they'll want you to forget all the other unsupported claims that preceded it.

Figarosmom

(13,702 posts)
2. Why would they cancel the program
Thu May 28, 2026, 02:51 AM
8 hrs ago

When they want to go there? Wasn't it musk that wants to live on Mars? Congress must not have asked him first when he was in charge.

dickthegrouch

(4,681 posts)
3. It's so much more fun going somewhere you know nothing about!
Thu May 28, 2026, 04:15 AM
7 hrs ago

And they can always claim plausible deniability if something on Mars actually bites an astronaut after arrival.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»NASA's Curiosity rover ha...