Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(37,021 posts)
Tue Dec 2, 2025, 07:01 AM 11 hrs ago

I just reviewed the slides my son gave for his Ph.D. proposal, and excerpted his paper on the topic.

It's way over my head.

That makes me a happy father; my son's work is way over my head.

It's all one can ever hope for, a son going far beyond himself.

6 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I just reviewed the slides my son gave for his Ph.D. proposal, and excerpted his paper on the topic. (Original Post) NNadir 11 hrs ago OP
You must be very proud Redleg 10 hrs ago #1
He is not in your research field, is he ? drray23 10 hrs ago #2
I get your point. My son did a paper on the benefits of clowns running the government but Wonder Why 8 hrs ago #3
No, he's a nuclear engineer, but that said, I have spent close to 40 years studying, in an autodidactic way... NNadir 8 hrs ago #4
I read the thesis of one of my troops going for his masters degree LogDog75 4 hrs ago #5
Passive Voice ProfessorGAC 54 sec ago #6

Redleg

(6,788 posts)
1. You must be very proud
Tue Dec 2, 2025, 07:59 AM
10 hrs ago

My Dad offered to proof-read my dissertation- until I told him how many pages it had. I think he was just kidding anyway.

drray23

(8,554 posts)
2. He is not in your research field, is he ?
Tue Dec 2, 2025, 07:59 AM
10 hrs ago

I had a similar experience at my daughter's phD defense. She got a phD in neuroscience from John Hopkins and I am a nuclear physicist so of course, I could not grasp most of it.

Wonder Why

(6,443 posts)
3. I get your point. My son did a paper on the benefits of clowns running the government but
Tue Dec 2, 2025, 09:36 AM
8 hrs ago

I failed kindergarten so it was beyond me.

I'm so proud of him.

NNadir

(37,021 posts)
4. No, he's a nuclear engineer, but that said, I have spent close to 40 years studying, in an autodidactic way...
Tue Dec 2, 2025, 09:54 AM
8 hrs ago

Last edited Tue Dec 2, 2025, 11:03 AM - Edit history (1)

...nuclear engineering.

Professionally chiefly I have focused, as a chemist, originally on the organic but later, the analytical chemistry, of pharmaceuticals.

A private interest is in environmental chemistry.

My interest in environmental chemistry drove me, for the last roughly 40 years, since Chernobyl blew up, to a very detailed way, to study the chemistry of used nuclear fuels, and ultimately, to an understanding of reactor engineering.

My son is a materials guy, and his focus as a nuclear engineer has been in the all important subject of nuclear materials.

I can certainly hold my own with him on many topics reactor engineering, and in fact, am in the process of writing up some ideas for him to keep in his back pocket when he becomes a professional or academic engineer. I have discussed these verbally with him, and he finds them credible. They concern transplutonium actinides and aspects of addressing issues connected with reduced fractions of delayed neutrons in certain of these actinide isotopes in fuel settings, related effects on criticality, passive heat removal and passive neutronic control and the neutron dynamics of certain fission product isotopes.

(I think these ideal are novel, but often when I think that, I found out that my presumed novelty is over stated.)

But yes, his topic is one out of my purview generally, radiation hardening of certain classes of alloys.

(His advisory team has advised him to narrow his focus. I told him to keep the refractory thermal parts he'll be cutting from the thesis in his back pocket; he'll need them ultimately, as he acknowledged. We had a laugh over the fact that is thesis will concern pressurized water reactors, an important topic, but one very limited in scope. If the world, or what's left of it, is to be saved we'll need to go way beyond PWRs, something of which he is very aware.)

Of course, the reason he's a nuclear engineer has something, not everything, to do with his father's interests expressed when he was a child and young man.

His undergraduate degree is in materials science and he did a one year masters in metallurgy on the advice of his undergraduate faculty, before going into nuclear engineering.

One pleasure I've had with him this weekend is to joke with him about fusion reactors. He has friends who know they won't be practical in their lifetimes, but took the jobs anyway, because of all the money flowing in. Perhaps it's a little unethical to take the money and run, but one has to live.

Congrats on your daughter's success.

LogDog75

(1,012 posts)
5. I read the thesis of one of my troops going for his masters degree
Tue Dec 2, 2025, 01:39 PM
4 hrs ago

He told me he needed an idea for his master's degree so I gave him one I had been thinking of that would improve our service to the base. I discussed with him how I envisioned us implementing this and asked him if he could improve it. He said he needed someone to oversee his project and would I do it which I said yes. After he completed his thesis, he asked me to read it and give him constructive criticism. Overall, he did a good job explaining the problem, gathering the facts, proposing solutions, choose his solution and how it would be implemented as well as the coordination on vertical and horizontal levels of management. The only thing I had problems with was the entire thesis was written in a passive voice as opposed to an active voice. He said the school preferred a passive voice for thesis papers. He submitted it and received his master's degree.

ProfessorGAC

(75,476 posts)
6. Passive Voice
Tue Dec 2, 2025, 06:11 PM
54 sec ago

That's usually preferred in technical papers.
Every time I'd write up project work & ran the grammar check on Word, it would flag passive voice, over &,over.
I just hit "ignore" over & over.
Eventually, I just ran spellchecker and left grammar check off.
Most writing doesn't like too much passive voice, but science trained people were encouraged to write thsg way.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»I just reviewed the slide...