The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsPumpkin pie is a tradition at Thanksgiving meals., but what other pies would you or have you served? Mine would be
Apple.
EYESORE 9001
(29,371 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)RainCaster
(13,347 posts)And coffee of course!
debm55
(53,682 posts)Emile
(39,642 posts)
debm55
(53,682 posts)Dulcinea
(9,517 posts)There used to be a restaurant near me that made coconut cream pie. I miss it!
2naSalit
(99,269 posts)I usually make apple and pecan, anybody wants something else, they can make it themselves.
debm55
(53,682 posts)SheltieLover
(75,527 posts)Ty he possibilities are endless.
debm55
(53,682 posts)electric_blue68
(25,221 posts)😄
markodochartaigh
(4,748 posts)with or without cherries. Quick, delicious, easy, no-bake, and healthy. Well, four out of five anyway.
debm55
(53,682 posts)yourout
(8,677 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)Polly Hennessey
(8,417 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)Keepthesoulalive
(2,060 posts)A pie of the Deep South.
unc70
(6,491 posts)So much better than pumpkin pie.
debm55
(53,682 posts)Walleye
(43,446 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)PoindexterOglethorpe
(28,377 posts)Never liked pumpkin myself.
debm55
(53,682 posts)TommieMommy
(2,550 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)CincyDem
(7,291 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)mike_c
(36,875 posts)I don't care for pumpkin pie.
debm55
(53,682 posts)OldBaldy1701E
(9,727 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)Trueblue Texan
(4,087 posts)A liquor store chain in Texas (Spec's) sells a bourbon pecan pie during the holidays...FABULOUS!
debm55
(53,682 posts)MIButterfly
(1,755 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)JMCKUSICK
(4,752 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)Dulcinea
(9,517 posts)Last edited Mon Nov 17, 2025, 12:33 PM - Edit history (1)
...but I also supply pecan pie & a baby apple pie for my husband because it's his favorite. That may sound like a lot of pie, but it never goes to waste!
debm55
(53,682 posts)lark
(25,795 posts)We also love Dutch Apple Crumb Pies, both homemade of course!
When mom was alive she made these awesome peanut butter pies that were to die for, but they were difficult to make with a homemade custard, and no one else loves them like I do so those have gone away - sadly!
debm55
(53,682 posts)added a special ingredient----love. May the memories of your mom, bring you blessings.
yorkster
(3,604 posts)Mince pie with coffee in the am. Yum.
Or the recipe on the back of the mincemeat jar - mincemeat for the bottom half of the.pie and apple for the top.
debm55
(53,682 posts)pandr32
(13,675 posts)I am Canadian born, so it is my preferred alternative to pecan. No corn syrup--just 100% maple syrup instead, and lots of toasted walnuts giving it a heavenly crunch. TO DIE FOR!!!
electric_blue68
(25,221 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)Last edited Mon Nov 17, 2025, 09:01 PM - Edit history (1)
pandr32
(13,675 posts)patphil
(8,568 posts)I grew up in upstate New York. That's apple country, and we would go apple picking every fall. I remember my mother, sister and I sitting in front of the TV watching football on the Sunday before Thanksgiving peeling apples while my older sister baked pies in the kitchen, with the smell of apple pie wafting through the house.
Ah, fond memories.
AltairIV
(999 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)memories with us.
John Coktosten
(165 posts)Just as a default setting, I love almost ALL pies. 😃 If y'all could see my fat ass in person, that would be obvious. 🤣
Here in the south, we also serve sweet potato pie for Turkey Day.
But seriously, how can you go wrong with other pies? Blueberry, strawberry, rhubarb, peach, apple, pecan, key lime, lemon meringue, etc., etc., etc......is there a bad pie?
😎
debm55
(53,682 posts)😊
no_hypocrisy
(53,947 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)Emile
(39,642 posts)
debm55
(53,682 posts)pnwest
(3,418 posts)would round out my trio of pie perfection.
debm55
(53,682 posts)Redleg
(6,795 posts)My family likes pecan pie, which is fine but not my favorite.
debm55
(53,682 posts)fargone
(530 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)OLDMDDEM
(2,967 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)OLDMDDEM
(2,967 posts)Coldwater
(722 posts)was always the third choice at my Thanksgiving Day table
debm55
(53,682 posts)Historic NY
(39,510 posts)there are several recipes. Its connection to Indians is thats its Indian corn meal.
milk, butter, molasses, eggs, spices, and cornmeal. I have made it several times its best when its baked long and on low heat. Most packets of corn meal have a recipe on it.
Pumpkin pie consistence, but better.
debm55
(53,682 posts)With cornbread and corn. I stopped making because no one ate it except me.
yorkster
(3,604 posts)woodsprite
(12,531 posts)But we also will have pumpkin, cherry, and egg custard pies.
debm55
(53,682 posts)rsdsharp
(11,637 posts)And were doing Pumpkin Mousse.
debm55
(53,682 posts)rsdsharp
(11,637 posts)Dorothy V
(427 posts)I don't care that much for pecan pie, it's too rich. But my guys love them and I've made so many over the years that I expect I could make one blindfolded and one hand tied behind my back.
debm55
(53,682 posts)too, I like with vanilla ice cream on top.
Lithos
(26,597 posts)Nothing finer.
debm55
(53,682 posts)electric_blue68
(25,221 posts)Chocolate Cream, pecan, apple, or coconut cream.
A then nyc (late '80's) small pie company made a ?sour cream walnut apple pie. Oh, it was sooo good! But when they got bigger they changed it. Not as good.
I wish I liked key lime, but it's too strong for me. (like regular limes)
Some people add chocolate, or chocolate chips to their pecan pie! Yum.
debm55
(53,682 posts)electric_blue68
(25,221 posts)debm55
(53,682 posts)PufPuf23
(9,673 posts)Growing up with family saw apple but also less common lemon meringue and huckleberry.
debm55
(53,682 posts)ProfessorGAC
(75,490 posts)For a cold pie, coconut cream.
debm55
(53,682 posts)Wolf Frankula
(3,801 posts)Peach pie. I don't eat pumpkins.