Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Polybius

(21,175 posts)
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 08:24 PM Sunday

Senate advances plan to end historic shutdown in bipartisan breakthrough

Last edited Mon Nov 10, 2025, 05:11 AM - Edit history (1)

Source: Politico

The Senate voted to break the shutdown stalemate Sunday, paving the way for the government to reopen as soon as later this week.

The 60-40 vote to take the first step toward ending the shutdown came hours after enough Democrats agreed to support a package that would fund multiple agencies and programs for the full fiscal year, and all others until Jan. 30, 2026.

In exchange, Democrats have a commitment from the Trump administration to rehire government workers fired at the start of the funding lapse, and the promise of a Senate floor vote in December on legislation to extend expiring Obamacare tax credits.

In the end, eight members of the Senate Democratic Caucus voted Sunday night, to advance the House-passed stopgap, which is being used as a vehicle for the larger funding deal.

Read more: https://www.politico.com/news/2025/11/09/government-funding-deal-on-track-to-advance-sunday-night-00644110



Passed by one vote...
89 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Senate advances plan to end historic shutdown in bipartisan breakthrough (Original Post) Polybius Sunday OP
Literally in tears angrychair Sunday #1
Good luck getting people to vote especially young people vercetti2021 Sunday #14
It's a gut punch, particularly after the momentum of Tuesday. yellow dahlia Sunday #27
Fuck this sucks. Initech Sunday #2
Guess the Farm and Grocery lobbies pulled some strings IbogaProject Sunday #3
And the travel and supply-chain businesses too nitpicked Monday #43
The overly rich again IbogaProject Monday #63
What the "deal" looks like progree Sunday #4
This will also fund Dep of Agriculture Deminpenn Sunday #6
Is a single word of your post to be backed by immediate legislation Bluetus Sunday #7
For the record on Schumer progree Sunday #15
I don't dispute that the 8 traitors knocked Schumer's legs from under him. But that just shows Bluetus Sunday #23
This was not him having his legs knocked out. This was protecting those who have elections coming up. Scrivener7 Monday #53
What??? Makes no sense. Bluetus Monday #55
You're not disagreeing with me. Not sure what you're saying makes no sense. Scrivener7 Monday #73
What doesn't make sense to me is ... Bluetus Monday #83
Yes. Again, we're not disagreeing. Schumer (or someone) wanted this. Rumor is that the airline industry Scrivener7 Monday #84
Agreed Bluetus Monday #87
Schumer orchestrated this chernabogg Sunday #28
They're still playing by outdated norms. Circa 2025, all Dems will feel the heat, regardless. nt Blasphemer Monday #34
In 2020ish, we learned that it only takes 2 assholes to make people hate the entire Dem Party Bluetus Monday #50
Conveniently, all those supporting it are not facing an election soon. Such leadership. Scrivener7 Monday #52
Correct - Schumer Opposes this deal KatyBR Monday #64
Unfortunately he doesn't stand for election until 2028 Bluetus Monday #81
It's my understanding that the 3 individual agency appropriations bills Deminpenn Monday #37
You suspect *WHAT* will pass? Bluetus Monday #51
First thing that came to mind reading the OP... IthinkThereforeIAM Monday #42
All of it is vague promises. Autumn Monday #75
Thune promised a vote? Now saying it will be in Dec. MY ASS! Bengus81 Monday #48
Stupidity squared! lark Monday #49
I feel your pain and your son's Jspur Monday #54
No shit popsdenver Monday #71
I agree with you 100 Jspur Monday #78
I hear you J popsdenver Monday #79
They are definitely going to attempt to destroy the remaining Jspur Monday #82
Schumer aint leading nothing quakerboy Monday #76
Absolutely nauseating. bagimin Sunday #5
It's still four votes short. James48 Sunday #8
What's taking so long? Polybius Sunday #9
Actually, someone else just said the last 4 are Republicans Polybius Sunday #10
Oh no. I'm heartbroken 💔 catrose Sunday #11
59-40 now Polybius Sunday #13
Post removed Post removed Sunday #12
Not a 'bunch' of spineless people, just the 8 dems necessary to pass the bill... Jack Valentino Sunday #17
Na i will vercetti2021 Sunday #18
Disappointed, but it couldn't go on forever... On the bright side, the HOUSE WILL HAVE TO RE-OPEN to Jack Valentino Sunday #16
After the House votes to release the files, is there any commitment that the Senate will pass it? Is there even a 24601 Sunday #21
Fuck no, and no. Volaris Sunday #31
No. And it won't happen. Lucy...... football. Autumn Monday #77
"consideration" berksdem Monday #80
Epic fail. Queso Delicioso Sunday #19
Agreed vercetti2021 Sunday #20
While I agree with that in principle.... AZ8theist Sunday #32
We have that now, apparently Queso Delicioso Monday #59
Still easier to gain influence within the Democratic party than to spin up a viable 3rd party 0rganism Monday #74
Bunch of centrist sellouts blue_jay Sunday #22
None of whom are up for election next year. Sneederbunk Sunday #26
Silver lining manicdem Sunday #24
But SNAP was Dump's hardball negotiation tactic AdamGG Monday #35
Exactly that's what people don't understand Jspur Monday #57
It also damages the argument re: who was to blame for the shutdown FBaggins Monday #58
If it's not SNAP it will be some other core thing that regular people need AdamGG Monday #88
It's over Polybius Sunday #25
ANYONE KNOW popsdenver Monday #72
Sure Polybius Monday #89
Democrats? ArizonaLib Sunday #29
Because they're traitors. Queso Delicioso Monday #60
So basically the deal is OrwellwasRight Sunday #30
No, read the details from AP story Deminpenn Monday #39
What are the details in that which you summarise as just "no" to all OrwellwasRight wrote? (nt) muriel_volestrangler Monday #45
I read the article. And summarized what I read. OrwellwasRight Monday #68
Cue the call for primaries... pecosbob Monday #33
These traitorous senators better have ... flying-skeleton Monday #36
So...starving people, gutting everything, all for nothing. I've been a dem my whole life, pounded pavement, phone airmid Monday #38
I am so sorry :( moonscape Monday #62
I'm sorry 😔 MustLoveBeagles Monday #65
One more positive thing is Deminpenn Monday #40
So now millions of people will be forced to go without healthcare because the premiums are too high. Lonestarblue Monday #41
Exactly ArizonaLib Monday #46
I wonder how close those 8 senators are to lobbyists and is there a correlation Mr. Sparkle Monday #44
Oh he definitely backed this. chernabogg Monday #47
Good points, Welcome to DU ! Mr. Sparkle Monday #69
Been here since 2004 at least. chernabogg Monday #70
Collaboration is now called "breakthrough". Miguelito Loveless Monday #56
I'm not too worried about his. Republicans will renege on any deal anyway. Ray Bruns Monday #61
After hear Mike Johnsons comment about he will NOT commit to bring ACA vote to the floor bluestarone Monday #66
"bipartisan breakthrough", I question that . republianmushroom Monday #67
Bipartisan my dick UT_democrat Monday #85
They own it weissmam Monday #86

angrychair

(11,488 posts)
1. Literally in tears
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 08:31 PM
Sunday

My frustration is boiling over.

WHY!!!! Special interest money? I don't know but it doesn't matter now and I can't control this or the repercussions for the Democratic Party.
Our future is just a pile of shit now.

 

vercetti2021

(10,481 posts)
14. Good luck getting people to vote especially young people
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 09:58 PM
Sunday

young people don't want Democrats they don't want GOP people either so they're just not going to vote

yellow dahlia

(4,014 posts)
27. It's a gut punch, particularly after the momentum of Tuesday.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 11:15 PM
Sunday

It's visceral. Everything is under attack.

People are going to die. Children are going to go hungry.

IbogaProject

(5,420 posts)
3. Guess the Farm and Grocery lobbies pulled some strings
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 08:37 PM
Sunday

Can't think what else changed in the last few days.

nitpicked

(1,546 posts)
43. And the travel and supply-chain businesses too
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 06:14 AM
Monday

Regarding travel:

https://www.sfgate.com/travel/article/flights-canceled-las-vegas-tourism-troubles-21147227.php

(snip)
The disruption in air travel could have a continued impact on the local economy if visitors choose to alter or cancel Las Vegas trips in the face of uncertainty. Las Vegas businesses joined almost 500 businesses nationwide in penning a letter to government officials urging them to end the shutdown. The letter, organized by the U.S. Travel Association and addressing top congressional leaders, said the U.S. travel industry has already lost $4 billion since the shutdown began and pleaded with them to open the government ahead of the busy Thanksgiving holiday travel.

On supply chains:

https://apnews.com/article/government-shutdown-airlines-shipping-cfeecb272743298e2e522eb351a28e31

Flight cuts from government shutdown strain a supply chain that’s already stretched thin
(snip)

IbogaProject

(5,420 posts)
63. The overly rich again
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 12:02 PM
Monday

Private Flights were canceled at twelve major airports, so that may have been a bigger factor. That campaign cash converting to a penson upon "retirement" scam hits us again.

progree

(12,548 posts)
4. What the "deal" looks like
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 08:41 PM
Sunday

From the OP's link
https://www.politico.com/news/2025/11/09/government-funding-deal-on-track-to-advance-sunday-night-00644110

As part of Democrats’ agreement to end the shutdown, Thune is promising Senate Democrats a vote in mid-December to extend Affordable Care Act subsidies that are due to expire at the end of the year without Congressional action. Democrats will also get to determine what extension bill receives that vote.

The government-opening agreement guarantees that federal employees laid off during the shutdown are re-hired and gives federal employees backpay. It also would require agencies to give written notice to Congress about the withdrawal of the so-called reduction-in-force notices issued during the funding lapse, plus provide the amount of back pay owed.

It would, as well, prevent some future firings with a blanket prohibition on reductions-in-force in any department or agency until at least the end date of the continuing resolution: Jan. 30, 2026.

. . . House Democratic leadership has insisted the health subsidies be addressed in legislation rather than a handshake compromise, especially as Johnson has refused to offer Democrats the same promise of a vote on an extension in his chamber.


The article goes on to discuss some of the opposition and opponents of the deal including Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries -- leaders of the Senate and House Democrats respectively

Deminpenn

(17,168 posts)
6. This will also fund Dep of Agriculture
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 09:09 PM
Sunday

and VA for the full fiscal year, so there would not be any disruption of SNAP and other food benefits. This is important.

It also puts some restraints on Vought/Trump with respect to the federal workforce.

The fact is, Dems were not going to get Rs to agree to an extension of ACA subsidies. Getting a vote will put Rs on record for or against subsidies.

This is not a bad deal and it will help Americans right away.

Bluetus

(1,923 posts)
7. Is a single word of your post to be backed by immediate legislation
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 09:29 PM
Sunday

or is it just a promise to allow a vote at some time in the future?

And everybody needs to understand the difference between allowing a vote (where every Republican can vote "no" ) on some hypothetical future bill (which the GOP can torpedo with poison pill amendments) versus an agreement to actually do any of the things we are demanding.

But I must admit I was wrong about one thing. I predicted that Schumer would capitulate within a day or two. Instead he took a month to capitulate -- waiting until we had all the leverage before folding like a cheap suit. Did everyone enjoy this theater production?

progree

(12,548 posts)
15. For the record on Schumer
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 10:06 PM
Sunday
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), who took heat from the progressive base for leading his party in shoring up the votes to prevent a government shutdown back in March, told reporters he would oppose the deal Sunday night.

Bluetus

(1,923 posts)
23. I don't dispute that the 8 traitors knocked Schumer's legs from under him. But that just shows
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 10:41 PM
Sunday

a) he had no real plan
b) he has no control over the Senate Dems

Yet, this place is still flooded with people who think it is a good thing to have Dem Senators believing they can be free agents, and that we must never speak of aggressively seeking and supporting primary opponents to get these assholes out of our party.

I have zero patience for anybody coming in with that free agent baloney.

Scrivener7

(57,827 posts)
53. This was not him having his legs knocked out. This was protecting those who have elections coming up.
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 09:38 AM
Monday

This is people being whipped to take one for the team so those who DO have elections coming up don't have to look bad.

I'll leave it to you to decide who did the whipping. As a New Yorker, I'll be voting for AOC in the primary. And I always thought of myself as the most moderate of moderate Democrats.

Bluetus

(1,923 posts)
55. What??? Makes no sense.
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 10:00 AM
Monday

The public strongly supported the Dem position on the shutdown. This was HELPING us electorally. You might have heard about some elections last week.

Maybe this is what Schumer was thinking. If so, that's even more reason that he needs to be gone TODAY.

Scrivener7

(57,827 posts)
73. You're not disagreeing with me. Not sure what you're saying makes no sense.
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 01:58 PM
Monday

Other than that he needs to be gone today. I wouldn't mind that, but I don't see how that realistically happens.

Bluetus

(1,923 posts)
83. What doesn't make sense to me is ...
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 02:39 PM
Monday

"This is people being whipped to take one for the team so those who DO have elections coming up don't have to look bad"

The American public at large, and a huge majority of Democrats, supported this hard line position, even though it meant some short-term pain. So I don't understand how snatching defeat from the jaws of victory protects Senators running next year. I think this cowardice hurts every single Democrat. The public wants to be with us, but they see us as untrustworthy because we cave in so easily. Most people don't really hate Democrats. They mostly really like the policies we talk about. But they see us as pathetic and feckless.

Scrivener7

(57,827 posts)
84. Yes. Again, we're not disagreeing. Schumer (or someone) wanted this. Rumor is that the airline industry
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 02:49 PM
Monday

has been throwing a hissy fit over lost Thanksgiving business, so some who are funded heavily by the airline industry were willing to go against the wishes of most Democrats to cave and keep the airline money coming in to fund their campaigns.

So Schumer (or someone) found a way to get around what Democrats want in order to keep the airline cash coming in, and to do it with only people who won't be immediately hurt by going against the vast majority of Democrats. I don't believe at all that this was a surprise to Schumer. I think the 8 were acting according to Schumer's wishes.

I don't support that at all. (Perhaps you thought I did and that is where the misunderstanding is coming from. I am just describing what I think happened. I'm not saying I support it.)

But I believe that is what happened. And I'm not alone in that belief.

Bluetus

(1,923 posts)
87. Agreed
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 05:31 PM
Monday

And having the airlines throw a hissy fit INCREASED our leverage. The GOP wont back off unless they feel enough pain, and we seem incapable of staying the course.

chernabogg

(22 posts)
28. Schumer orchestrated this
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 11:16 PM
Sunday

He set it up so that the 8 dems who voted for it are not facing reelection anytime soon.

Blasphemer

(3,534 posts)
34. They're still playing by outdated norms. Circa 2025, all Dems will feel the heat, regardless. nt
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 01:22 AM
Monday

Bluetus

(1,923 posts)
50. In 2020ish, we learned that it only takes 2 assholes to make people hate the entire Dem Party
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 09:18 AM
Monday

Now we have 8 assholes who have identified themselves, and probably another 20 right behind them.

Can we finally talk about hitting these people with primary opponents without the DU bully squad getting us suspended?

Scrivener7

(57,827 posts)
52. Conveniently, all those supporting it are not facing an election soon. Such leadership.
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 09:34 AM
Monday


That's the record.

KatyBR

(203 posts)
64. Correct - Schumer Opposes this deal
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 12:16 PM
Monday

That was also reported in the Washington Post today.

Bluetus

(1,923 posts)
81. Unfortunately he doesn't stand for election until 2028
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 02:33 PM
Monday

But the caucus should be demanding a different leader in the next session starting in January, 2026

Deminpenn

(17,168 posts)
37. It's my understanding that the 3 individual agency appropriations bills
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 04:37 AM
Monday

that fund through the end of FY26 (Sept 30 2026) have already been negotiated between Rs and Ds as well as between the House and Senate. They are ready to go. The agriculture (farm) bill is the one that funds SNAP and other food benefits. The VA is also funded through the end of FY26. The only bad look is Congress making sure it's funded through Sept.

The CR funds everything else through the end of Jan. It is NOT the same CR passed by the House.

The vote on subsidies is scheduled for mid-Dec. Thune's credibility is on the line so I believe that will happen and I suspect it will pass.

There are also protections for federal workers ensuring back pay and that they will be re-hired if they were "RIF'd".

Here is the AP story: https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/government-shutdown-reaches-40th-day-050134288.html

Bluetus

(1,923 posts)
51. You suspect *WHAT* will pass?
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 09:32 AM
Monday

There is no bill for restoring the ACA subsidies. There is zero chance that ever comes back. Republicans have been fighting for this day for 16 years.

Sure, Thune will let Schumer write a bill and put it to a vote. And there will be plenty of Republicans voting against it to kill it, and maybe they will joined by their 8 new pals.

I don't know if Schumer lost control of his caucus or if this was his extra clever plan all along. But I do know that in sports parlance, you can't fire the whole team so you have to fire the coach. And in Schumer's case, he has fought against primary opponents all along. I stopped donating to the DNC years ago, and I will not give them a penny until they get behind the idea of a unified party with a common vision and a commitment to achieving major progress, including the willingness to push out the Senators and Representatives that are working against us. This process should start with replacing Schumer. And at this point, I'm planning to allocate a major portion of my political donations to AOC to get Schumer out of the Senate altogether.

We should be talking openly about who would be a better person to have in the Minority Leader position. I'm thinking Markey, Merkeley, Van Hollen. People who aren't afraid to talk plainly and forcefully. Definitely not people like Booker, Schiff and others who obfuscate everything they say. Maybe Hirono. She might kick some real ass.

IthinkThereforeIAM

(3,250 posts)
42. First thing that came to mind reading the OP...
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 06:00 AM
Monday

... do not trust THUNE or any Republican to stick to their word. I have gotten too many mealy mouthed responses from Thune when writing his office concerning issues. He tends to say much, yet nothing concerning the issue at hand.

lark

(25,707 posts)
49. Stupidity squared!
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 08:57 AM
Monday

The Senate already voted on this and it did not pass and it won't pass whenever (if ever) the R[s deign to hold true to their promises - which generally meas never ever!! I am ashamed of the 8, and ashamed of the party that allowed this and my fear for America only grows! My son relies on the ACA and now won't be able to afford it, and he really needs surgery.

Jspur

(773 posts)
54. I feel your pain and your son's
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 09:57 AM
Monday

pain since I also rely on the ACA. I lost my federal contracting job several months ago due to DOGE and since then I have been on ACA. I have been working gig jobs to stay afloat until I can get a real job and the ACA was helping me out tremendously. It really sucks that your son and myself got screwed over by these spineless Democrats. I feel now until I can get a real job that I will be playing Russian roulette by not having insurance since you never know when you will need it. What a ridiculous country that we live in with this type of nonsense occurring.

popsdenver

(1,017 posts)
71. No shit
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 01:33 PM
Monday

but then......how are a group of people gonna vote, regardless of party, who are guaranteed retirement and medical for life after serving just one term??????

"There is no bill for restoring the ACA subsidies. There is zero chance that ever comes back. Republicans have been fighting for this day for 16 years"

This, for all time, represents the final nail in the coffin.....

Once again, They" continue to walk down the jungle path, swatting at mosquitoes, completely and totally oblivious to the herd of charging elephants................

We had nothing to lose, anywhere near as important as ACA. And they caved.................

They have been caving for over four decades, and now......they wonder how this can happen????????????????????

Jspur

(773 posts)
78. I agree with you 100
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 02:10 PM
Monday

percent. I was telling my best friend last night who is also a progressive of how this truly was the last nail in the coffin because now the democrats have nothing to offer me since I was relying on ACA. Now without it what can they sell me? Even fear tactics won't do it since I lost my job several months ago so what else can get worse for me. I know they will try with saying stuff like food prices will go up but my response to that is well I guess I rather starve to death that live in this society. Fear tactics is definitely not going to work for me now. I have already made peace with the possibility of death.

I'll never vote for a Republican but if the Democrats ever want my vote again I need to see them campaign on offering tangibles to me such as universal healthcare, and other economic benefits. I'm not voting out of fear anymore. I did that the last 3 presidential election cycles. I'm done with that.

popsdenver

(1,017 posts)
79. I hear you J
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 02:25 PM
Monday

I am going minute to minute on whether to throw in the towel...............

The Repubs, (and the 2025 Fascists) have the destruction of ACA on the very top of their list for over sixteen years when Obama got it in......

IT IS ALL DOWNHILL FROM HERE IN...........

Next on the list is Social Security being turned over to private investment firms crap shoot. Then comes a ton of other stuff....
Medicare, medicaid, our beloved Constitution, although it is already ignored by them and is in shreds.........The fascist take over, end of posse comatatus, and when we rebel, the Insurrection act, Martial law, and the tyranny within The Corporate Fascist of America replacing the USA....

The list is endless.........and in my opinion....THE shot heard round the world.......

WASF

Jspur

(773 posts)
82. They are definitely going to attempt to destroy the remaining
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 02:37 PM
Monday

safety net programs. I see the Republicans some how injecting poison pills within SSN, Medicaid, and Medicare. The poison pill will be some way tying privatization to all of those programs. These poison pills will eventually take down all of those programs.

Polybius

(21,175 posts)
9. What's taking so long?
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 09:39 PM
Sunday

According to someone on TV, those last 4 votes are Democrats. No clue if that's true or not though.

Polybius

(21,175 posts)
10. Actually, someone else just said the last 4 are Republicans
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 09:42 PM
Sunday

John Cornyn (R-TX), Rick Scott (R-FL), Ron Johnson (R-WI), and Mike Lee (R-UT).

Response to Polybius (Original post)

Jack Valentino

(4,030 posts)
17. Not a 'bunch' of spineless people, just the 8 dems necessary to pass the bill...
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 10:22 PM
Sunday



Personally, I didn't expect this quite yet, either... and I won't defend it---
but to denigrate the whole party for the actions of a few is wrong.

Jack Valentino

(4,030 posts)
16. Disappointed, but it couldn't go on forever... On the bright side, the HOUSE WILL HAVE TO RE-OPEN to
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 10:19 PM
Sunday

pass the modified bill, and Johnson will have no more excuse to avoid swearing in the new Democratic member who will provide the final signature needed to force consideration of releasing the EPSTEIN FILES!

24601

(4,127 posts)
21. After the House votes to release the files, is there any commitment that the Senate will pass it? Is there even a
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 10:26 PM
Sunday

realistic expectation that the Senate will invoke cloture to even vote on it?

Volaris

(11,275 posts)
31. Fuck no, and no.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 11:43 PM
Sunday

And even if I'm wrong, it still had to go to Trump for signature. There's no way there's 2/3 override in the senate.

Queso Delicioso

(168 posts)
19. Epic fail.
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 10:25 PM
Sunday

Party members who identify as democratic socialists should spin off a new party now; separate themselves from this moribund entity that the democratic party has become.

 

vercetti2021

(10,481 posts)
20. Agreed
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 10:26 PM
Sunday

We need an actual progressive party. Not a spineless centrist party that bends over to fascism at every turn.

AZ8theist

(6,979 posts)
32. While I agree with that in principle....
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 11:57 PM
Sunday

..in reality that would only ensure a permanent Reich Wing government in America.

Queso Delicioso

(168 posts)
59. We have that now, apparently
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 10:58 AM
Monday

We have only the barest fig leaf covering the reality that we don't actually have a democracy anymore. NYC is the only real outlier and you can see how the establishment class feels about how that went down.

0rganism

(25,405 posts)
74. Still easier to gain influence within the Democratic party than to spin up a viable 3rd party
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 01:58 PM
Monday

Our electoral system really leans into a duopoly, the senate's shitty behavior yesterday didn't change that. So we're faced with the age-old question of "whether tis better to brave the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune or by opposing end them."

blue_jay

(150 posts)
22. Bunch of centrist sellouts
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 10:29 PM
Sunday

hope one of them decides to convert to being an actual patriotic, non-traitorous American (like those who actually understand the principles this country was founded on) and changes their vote, versus the constantly, predictably caving in, or dare I say chickening out, wuss asses they are being. But honestly, am pretty sure it circles back to $$$ and who owns them.

manicdem

(531 posts)
24. Silver lining
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 10:43 PM
Sunday

Although the shutdowns will continue after January and there's no agreement on the ACA, at least SNAP gets funded for a year so the poor don't go hungry.

AdamGG

(1,832 posts)
35. But SNAP was Dump's hardball negotiation tactic
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 02:31 AM
Monday

and he succeeded with it, so he'll use extreme tactics like that in the future.

Jspur

(773 posts)
57. Exactly that's what people don't understand
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 10:15 AM
Monday

which is Trump will use SNAP as cudgel every time to get whatever he wants out of the Democrats. This is not a one time deal with Trump when it comes to SNAP. He will do it every single time he feels he has to extract concessions out of the Democrats.

FBaggins

(28,589 posts)
58. It also damages the argument re: who was to blame for the shutdown
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 10:43 AM
Monday

Was the shutdown because Republicans wouldn't keep healthcare subsidies? Many people thought so... but now the shutdown is over and republicans didn't keep healthcare subsidies.

Was it because of the Democrats filibustering a clean CR? Some polls indicated that a growing number said that wasn't the case... but now Democrats have ended their filibuster and the government is opening.

AdamGG

(1,832 posts)
88. If it's not SNAP it will be some other core thing that regular people need
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 06:57 PM
Monday

He'll never cut corporate subsidies or funds for farmers in red states, but he's now much more likely to hold other essential funds for working people hostage and expect to get rewarded for it. It's kind of predictable that Mandahmi will have trouble providing free bus fare once the Dept. of Transportation withholds all of NYC's funding.

OrwellwasRight

(5,306 posts)
30. So basically the deal is
Sun Nov 9, 2025, 11:41 PM
Sunday

The status quo ante, plus a meaningless Republican promise to “hold a vote” in December on the ACA (which vote, if held, will be meaningless as even if it were to miraculously pass the Senate, it would die in the House). So the Democrats got nothing at all out of the shut down except a cementing of their reputation as feckless. SAD!

As a former federal employee (most recently left in 2023 to be clear), I would not view the Dems as heroes simply because they negotiated to let me keep the pay and employment status I would have had before the shutdown. I would wonder why in the world they put me through the trauma of withheld pay and maybe being RIF’ed without getting a single thing out it. What, indeed, was the point?

What a sad tragic waste for a party that was finally beginning to demonstrate backbone and cohesion.

muriel_volestrangler

(105,212 posts)
45. What are the details in that which you summarise as just "no" to all OrwellwasRight wrote? (nt)
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 07:14 AM
Monday

OrwellwasRight

(5,306 posts)
68. I read the article. And summarized what I read.
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 01:01 PM
Monday

There really isn’t anything much in the deal.

Guaranteeing people the pay and jobs they had before the shutdown (yes, a good thing), but that is just the “status quo ante,” meaning what people would have had anyway, had there been no shut down. And a vague promise of a vote on subsidies, which I guess you can argue has potential, but any successful action is remote in time and not guaranteed to pass either house of Congress, much less be signed by the President. In your view, what have I left out?

Don’t get me wrong, I would not oppose a real deal in which the Dems got something real and tangible even if it what short of their goal of a one year extension of the current level of ACA subsidies. They even could have traded for something else *meaningful* in the health care space and spun that as an achievement.

But this particular deal looks like a full cave in and will be spun as a full cave in. One reason I am angry about it is that this kind of capitulating behavior is what makes those who do not follow politics and government as closely as we on DU do feel that the Dems are feckless cowards. IMHO: We cannot afford to feed that perception if we want to win future elections.

flying-skeleton

(808 posts)
36. These traitorous senators better have ...
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 02:31 AM
Monday

These traitorous senators better have gotten rich from surrendering because they just ended their political careers and will have to live their lives in shame ‼️

I will donate to every one who primaries these traitors ‼️

airmid

(525 posts)
38. So...starving people, gutting everything, all for nothing. I've been a dem my whole life, pounded pavement, phone
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 04:48 AM
Monday

banking, giving till it hurt….and this is the return. I’m exhausted y’all..we will be cut now anyway so there is no recovery in our household. At 61 the jobs are not there. I’m trying to keep two disabled veterans alive and myself and they are taking everything, even my access to healthcare. I’m not sure what to do at this point.

Deminpenn

(17,168 posts)
40. One more positive thing is
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 04:54 AM
Monday

that because this is a different bill than the CR passed by the House, Johnson will have to bring the House back into session to vote on it.

While there he will have to swear in the new AZ rep who will be the 218th vote on the Espstein discharge peitition.

Lonestarblue

(13,125 posts)
41. So now millions of people will be forced to go without healthcare because the premiums are too high.
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 05:57 AM
Monday

I do not believe Republicans will ever allow ACA subsidies again. They want to kill the program and have no concerns if people die from lack of medical care. By caving to Republicans, the Democrats prevented some people from starving but consigned others to perhaps dying with no treatment for diseases. Medicaid might help a few, but the Big Ugly Bill cut that also, and red states especially are spending millions to prevent people from getting Medicaid.

We are a dysfunctional country run by oligarchs solely for the benefit of oligarchs.

ArizonaLib

(1,282 posts)
46. Exactly
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 07:22 AM
Monday

Even if we win the senate, we will need to clear a filibuster proof vote and a Trump veto.

Mr. Sparkle

(3,554 posts)
44. I wonder how close those 8 senators are to lobbyists and is there a correlation
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 06:33 AM
Monday

The reports i'm reading is that chuck did not back this

chernabogg

(22 posts)
47. Oh he definitely backed this.
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 08:20 AM
Monday

Last edited Mon Nov 10, 2025, 04:15 PM - Edit history (1)

And even if he didn’t, it just shows what a weak fuck he is. He’s done, he should retire today.

Ray Bruns

(5,788 posts)
61. I'm not too worried about his. Republicans will renege on any deal anyway.
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 11:16 AM
Monday

And in a couple of months we are all going to be right back here.

Never trust a republican.

bluestarone

(20,783 posts)
66. After hear Mike Johnsons comment about he will NOT commit to bring ACA vote to the floor
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 12:32 PM
Monday

ALL Senate Dems. should refuse this deal and vote NO! They should have been assured that the house would bring it to the floor vote.

weissmam

(910 posts)
86. They own it
Mon Nov 10, 2025, 04:27 PM
Monday

Now whatever happens to health care premiums and health insurance the GOP owns it

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Senate advances plan to e...