Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

BumRushDaShow

(163,346 posts)
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 05:25 AM Nov 7

Judge slams ICE for 'fictional' case seeking to jail migrant for 20 years.The agent involved cut himself breaking window

Source: The Independent

Thursday 06 November 2025 18:15 EST


A Texas federal judge had scathing words for the Trump administration last month when he dismissed a “largely fictional” case against a Honduran immigrant who officials accused of harming an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent who broke the man’s car window during a stop. “The Government’s conduct was—and has been—outrageous,” U.S. District Judge Xavier Rodriguez, a George W. Bush appointee, wrote in his October 20 ruling tossing the case.

The controversy centered around a June stop in San Antonio, where federal agents and Texas troopers arrested Jaime Alberto Quintanilla-Chavez, 35, a Honduran immigrant married to a U.S. citizen. After getting a tip from a Texas woman who claimed Quintanilla-Chavez was in the country illegally and had abused her daughter, officers considered the man an “easy target” and prepared to arrest him.

During the stop, agents ordered him to open the doors of his truck and soon broke the driver’s-side window. In the process, a Homeland Security Investigations officer, William Carl, suffered a cut to his arm. Federal officials accused Quintanilla-Chavez of impeding officers and harming the agent, seeking a sentence of up to 20 years.

In his ruling, Judge Rodriguez called the government’s description of the stop “largely fictional,” pointing to a variety of issues with the stop: agents lacked a warrant; there was no evidence the Honduran had an order of removal from the country; and officers only asked about his immigration status after they forcibly removed him from the truck and handcuffed him.

Read more: https://www.the-independent.com/news/world/americas/us-politics/ice-agent-texas-case-car-window-b2860351.html



Full headline: Judge slams ICE for ‘fictional’ case seeking to jail migrant for 20 years. The agent involved cut himself breaking the Honduran man’s car window
17 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Judge slams ICE for 'fictional' case seeking to jail migrant for 20 years.The agent involved cut himself breaking window (Original Post) BumRushDaShow Nov 7 OP
Each of these cases must be documented James48 Nov 7 #1
What about outing the unnamed "woman" who possibly filed a false complaint? the nelm Nov 7 #2
Ask George Stinney, Emmett Till and Jesse Washington. AZLD4Candidate Nov 7 #7
Yep, revenge IbogaProject Nov 7 #14
WTF has the USA become? RazorbackExpat Nov 7 #3
This is the USA that black people have known since its founding. BumRushDaShow Nov 7 #5
I got a Scholastic book called "Runaway Slave: The Story of Harriet Tubman" RazorbackExpat Nov 7 #6
"Dale Bumpers" BumRushDaShow Nov 7 #8
I remember the first time Bumpers ran for governor RazorbackExpat Nov 7 #9
As a CSPAN watcher BumRushDaShow Nov 7 #10
Black and Indigenous people Bayard Nov 7 #15
I was going to add the First Peoples but they also had "treaties" with the invaders, some still in effect BumRushDaShow Nov 7 #16
I automatically assume ICE or Border control or any DOJ official is LYING. mackdaddy Nov 7 #4
This why they hide their faces. NHvet Nov 7 #11
The judge should report the prosecutors to the bar for discipline. And Jaime should sue for his attorney's fees. SunSeeker Nov 7 #12
The American Gestapo at work. republianmushroom Nov 7 #13
K&R ck4829 Monday #17

the nelm

(207 posts)
2. What about outing the unnamed "woman" who possibly filed a false complaint?
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 07:57 AM
Nov 7

What kind of monster does that?

AZLD4Candidate

(6,716 posts)
7. Ask George Stinney, Emmett Till and Jesse Washington.
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 08:44 AM
Nov 7

Same conditions with them, except they were tortured and murdered and Stinney was executed at 14 years old. White person lied about all three.

IbogaProject

(5,420 posts)
14. Yep, revenge
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 12:14 PM
Nov 7

The coward "informant" likely had one or more angles. Like their partner is seeking that poor guy's position at a workplace, or a rivalry with the man's wife. And the true crime is ICE or DHS never took it to a judge to get an actual warrant.

RazorbackExpat

(768 posts)
3. WTF has the USA become?
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 08:15 AM
Nov 7

Although I have to admit, I kind of saw this coming, beginning in the '80s and '90s, and especially after GWB stole the 2000 election and rammed through his unAmerican "Patriot" Act.

BumRushDaShow

(163,346 posts)
5. This is the USA that black people have known since its founding.
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 08:26 AM
Nov 7

And it hasn't stopped. In fact, it is getting worse again because everything is being purged from the history of this country regarding that abhorent mistreatment - both during and after slavery.

RazorbackExpat

(768 posts)
6. I got a Scholastic book called "Runaway Slave: The Story of Harriet Tubman"
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 08:38 AM
Nov 7

in 1966, one year after the Civil War Centennial ended. It made me hate my former slave state of Arkansas, even though it hadn't been a slave state in 100+ years. Arkansas finally came to terms with its past in the late '60s, and the state's Democratic Party began to distance itself from that in the '70s with New Democrats such as Dale Bumpers, David Pryor, and even Bill Clinton.

RazorbackExpat

(768 posts)
9. I remember the first time Bumpers ran for governor
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 09:13 AM
Nov 7

That was in 1970, when he was running against then-Governor Winthrop Rockefeller. Even though Rockefeller was a Republican, he was a progressive in the style of Robert LaFollette. So, it was kind of a win-win situation. Bumpers won, then 4 years later he challenged the esteemed J. William Fulbright in the Democratic primary for the US Senate, and won. He went on to become a very admired US Senator.

I met him once, at a Jefferson-Jackson Day picnic in Little Flock (a small community in Benton County), and was really impressed with the man. He served Arkansas well.

BumRushDaShow

(163,346 posts)
10. As a CSPAN watcher
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 09:32 AM
Nov 7

and particularly when our cable (Comcast) finally added CSPAN2 (which shows the Senate), there were a number of "old school, southern gentleman" Senators like him and the indefatigable Robert Byrd.

And since you mention a Rockefeller Senator - the other liberal one was Jay Rockefeller in WV, who is sorely missed!

BumRushDaShow

(163,346 posts)
16. I was going to add the First Peoples but they also had "treaties" with the invaders, some still in effect
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 01:03 PM
Nov 7

and they still retained SOME of their native land.

But EVERYTHING was taken from the enslaved brought here from Africa.

mackdaddy

(1,909 posts)
4. I automatically assume ICE or Border control or any DOJ official is LYING.
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 08:26 AM
Nov 7

We have had problems with some part of the 'Thin Blue Line' lying for some time.

But anyone in this administration is just going to spout whatever bullshit they want, facts be damned.

And they are trying to prosecute James Comey for lying in a mishmash question in a senate hearing?

We now know the Statue of limitations is 5 years. These morons should remember that.

NHvet

(261 posts)
11. This why they hide their faces.
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 09:44 AM
Nov 7

So when the day comes for accountability for their actions, no will know who they were.

SunSeeker

(57,262 posts)
12. The judge should report the prosecutors to the bar for discipline. And Jaime should sue for his attorney's fees.
Fri Nov 7, 2025, 10:48 AM
Nov 7

The Hyde Amendment to the Equal Access to Justice Act, 18 U.S.C. § 3006A note, permits criminal defendants to recover reasonable attorney’s fees (a) if they are acquitted, and (2) “if the position of the United States was vexatious, frivolous or in bad faith.” If the defendant wins, then the agency must pay the award out of its budget. https://kmlawfirm.com/2017/08/28/can-a-defendant-get-attorneys-fees-if-hes-acquitted-and-theres-prosecutorial-misconduct/#:~:text=The%20Hyde%20Amendment%20to%20the%20Equal%20Access,faith.%E2%80%9D%20Good%20luck%20proving%20that%20last%20part.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Judge slams ICE for 'fict...