Former A.G. Eric Holder Urges Democrats to Reform 'Broken' Supreme Court Once Back in Power
Source: MEDIAite
Nov 3rd, 2025, 8:40 pm
Former U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder called on Democrats to reform the Supreme Court should they win a trifecta in 2028 on Monday, calling it a broken institution that was causing an untold amount of damage to the fabric of the country.
If you look at whats happening at the district court level, at the court of appeals level, it doesnt matter who the president was who appointed the judge. The judges have ruled, I think, courageously and correctly, said Holder during an interview with liberal media company Meidas Touch. Its only when you get to the Supreme Court that you see these problems start to arise. He continued:
And its the use of, this overuse of the shadow docket. You know, by taking these cases and decided them, essentially deciding them, without hearing any oral argument, with any adequate briefing. You know, deciding these really important matters in that way challenges the legitimacy of the court and does an untold amount of damage to the fabric, legal fabric of this nation.
I think the reality is, and it pains me to say this, I think the Supreme Court is a broken institution and its something that has to be, I think, a part of the national conversation in 26 and in 28. What are we gonna do about the Supreme Court? And I think that we have to think about, again, talking about the acquisition, the use of power, if there is a Democratic trifecta in 2028, and I think the possibility of that is pretty good.
Read more: https://www.mediaite.com/politics/it-pains-me-to-say-this-former-a-g-eric-holder-urges-democrats-to-reform-broken-supreme-court-once-back-in-power/
Full headline: It Pains Me to Say This: Former A.G. Eric Holder Urges Democrats to Reform Broken Supreme Court Once Back in Power
Hotler
(13,617 posts)sop
(16,882 posts)I recall pointing out to the "yeah, but Hillary's emails" crowd back in 2016 what it would mean if Trump had the chance to appoint several Supreme Court justices.
everyonematters
(3,972 posts)Abstractartist
(384 posts)You dont, thats why it is imperative that the Senate goes Democrats and we have democrats that care about justice, not blue dog dems that are there to pad their wallets, stock market gains and free healthcare. The senate needs to be at least 53 democrats, because with Fetterman, you lose a vote. Sinema and Manchin were our losing votes with Joe Biden term. Once the senate is back in dem control, President (democrat) can then add justices to the court
everyonematters
(3,972 posts)Abstractartist
(384 posts)Ok great, but lets hope the 10% is not a time when we need EVERY DEMOCRAT LEADER ON BOARD.
SunSeeker
(57,262 posts)Please don't adopt Republicans' incorrect trolling terminology.
Ok how about if I just say ..GET EVERY DEMOCRAT ON BOARD. There, I removed leader .
Abstractartist
(384 posts)LPBBEAR
(599 posts)for removal of several of these corrupt judges. Alito and Thomas for corruption. Some of the others for lying to Congress. Get rid of them.
Bluetus
(1,923 posts)Last edited Tue Nov 4, 2025, 02:04 PM - Edit history (1)
Why can't Democrats just come out and say things without diluting all meeaning and impact?
Translation: If we ever expect to have the power to make the changes he tepidly hints at in the ever-so gentle way, we must SELL THIS IDEA to the public by making it prominent in our campaigns.
People don't want a freaking "national conversation", damn it. They want bold leaders with bold plans and a party that will come together around these action-oriented plans. There is one such plan floating around that has these strong points:
Overturn Citizens United
No personal use of PAC money, even after retiring
Codify Women's Right to Choose
Term Limits and highest code of ethics for SCOTUS
Get Rid of the Electoral College
Outlaw Gerrymandering Nationwide
Return Fairness Doctrine in Media
Universal Healthcare for ALL
Ban Stock Trading While in Congress
5 year wait before taking jobs in industries overseen/regulated when in office
Cap Congress Salary at 1.5x Median Income of Their District
Tax Billionaires Out of Existence
Tax Unrealized Gains Used as Loan Collateral
Tax Mega-Churches involved in political activity
Raise Federal Minimum Wage to $20/hr
Eliminate the Presidential pardon privilege
Not a "national conversation" It is a RECOVERY PLAN for the nation.
hay rick
(9,202 posts)oldguy_tls
(22 posts)When he was a candidate for President in 2016 he proposed the following:
1. Expand the court to 15 justices
2. Reserve 5 seats each for Democrats and Republicans to fill
3. Reserve 5 seats for the other 10 justices to agree upon and nominate
I would add that any nominee be required to have a straight up or down vote within 30 days of the nomination being conveyed to the Senate. If the Senate fails to hold that vote then they would each have their paychecks docked one months pay for each month or part that they fail to hold that vote.
This would bring SCOTUS as close to an ideologically balanced court as humanly possible.
Obviously, this would require a Constitutional amendment since the power to nominate justices is reserved for the President