FBI Director Kash Patel faces scrutiny for inaccurately saying Kirk killer had been caught
Source: Reuters
September 11, 2025 3:26 PM EDT Updated 1 hour ago
WASHINGTON, Sept 11 (Reuters) - Kash Patel faced his biggest test yet as FBI director as current and former officials criticized his inaccurate statement that a suspect had been caught in the fatal shooting of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, a prominent ally of President Donald Trump.
Moments before officials on the scene of the shooting in Orem, Utah, briefed the press on Wednesday, Patel announced on social media that the person responsible for the shooting was in custody. That claim was quickly contradicted by local officials, leading to hours of confusion before the FBI clarified that two people had been questioned and then released following the incident. Current and former U.S. officials called Patel's announcement counterproductive.
At the outset of an investigation, much of the initial intelligence is typically wrong or slightly off. That's why what he did yesterday has never been done by any FBI director before him, or any division leadership before," said retired FBI agent Dan Brunner. "The investigators need to sort through all the initial intelligence before putting out factual evidence ... FBI does not run investigations on social media.
A White House source, granted anonymity to discuss internal discussions, called Patel's announcement unprofessional and said "his performance is really not acceptable to the White House or the American public" and will be addressed.
Read more: https://www.reuters.com/world/us/fbi-director-kash-patel-faces-scrutiny-inaccurately-saying-kirk-killer-had-been-2025-09-11/

bigworld
(1,813 posts)No need to expect him to start now
pwb
(12,356 posts)It is their way.
maxsolomon
(37,349 posts)Scrutiny is so 2024.
progressoid
(51,899 posts)yardwork
(68,018 posts)SunSeeker
(56,638 posts)Total unprofessional clown. Those two men he previously announced as arrested suspects, before the FBI had even interrogated them, immediately were doxxed and deluged with death threats to them and their families. Hope they sue the shit out of Patel and the feds.
question everything
(50,954 posts)Blues Heron
(7,545 posts)bluedigger
(17,319 posts)DrFunkenstein
(8,832 posts)Stop being so cynical!
BumRushDaShow
(160,061 posts)Wonder what is up?
Response to BumRushDaShow (Original post)
fujiyamasan This message was self-deleted by its author.
BumRushDaShow
(160,061 posts)They play act because they have ZERO idea about what they are doing (and don't even care).
Bengus81
(9,351 posts)BumRushDaShow
(160,061 posts)(which is why the result of someone from "above" dragging him out of a restaurant to declare (in his best Al Haig voice) - "As of now, I am in control here", blurting out something "official sounding", and finally going back to finish his meal, MIGHT "finish his career"! )
LetMyPeopleVote
(169,744 posts)The FBI director was already facing questions about whether he was up to the task. Those questions grew louder this week.
Kash Patelâs difficulties and embarrassments at the FBI do not go unnoticed
— Raymond Norman (@raymondnorman.bsky.social) 2025-09-12T20:44:13.749Z
The FBI director was already facing questions about whether he was up to the task. Those questions grew louder this week.
www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddo...
https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/kash-patel-fbi-problems-rcna230812
A day later, according to The New York Times latest reporting and multiple sources, Patel convened an online meeting with 200 agents to discuss the manhunt, launched into profanity-laced tirades and whined about not being kept in the loop by his subordinates. From the article:
The killing of Mr. Kirk on Wednesday not only poses a challenge to agents racing to find the shooter, it also represents a grave leadership test for Mr. Patel. His swift pronouncements about the inquiry have revived concerns about his lack of experience, obsession with social media and purge of some of the bureaus most experienced investigators, according to current and former officials, most of whom spoke on the sensitive matter on the condition of anonymity.
......Thats plainly true. Patels tenure has featured a variety of embarrassments and brazenly partisan personnel purges. Things went from bad to worse this week when three former senior FBI officials filed a brutal federal lawsuit, which characterized Patels bureau as fixated on politically motivated retribution and consumed by the whims of a Trump White House.
In case that werent quite enough, Patel, just a few weeks ago, fired the highly regarded head of the FBI field office Salt Lake City for reasons that have not yet been explained and given that the Kirk shooting happened in Utah, the directors decision received obvious and unavoidable scrutiny anew over the last couple of days.....
Patel has been battling suspicions that he simply wasnt up for the job ever since. He still enjoys the White House's backing, but he nevertheless took additional steps toward confirming those suspicions this week.