General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsAnti-ice protestors get 50 year and 70 year sentences "to send a message" to those w/ similar views
https://www.reddit.com/r/news/s/bydCDar4oFA group of Texas protesters convicted of terrorism charges received unusually harsh sentences of at least 50 years in prison on Tuesday in a closely watched case that was widely seen as a test case of the Trump administrations efforts to crack down on dissent.
After a three week jury trial, the nine activists were all found guilty of a slew of criminal charges in March, stemming from a Fourth of July protest at an immigrant detention facility in Alvarado, Texas, south of Fort Worth. The demonstrators arrived late at night with a plan to set off fireworks as part of a noise demonstration to show solidarity with those detained inside. A few of the protesters spontaneously broke off from the main group and vandalized cars in the parking lot, a guard shack, slashed the tires on a government van and broke a security camera. When a police officer arrived on the scene and drew his weapon, one of the activists fired an AR-15 from the woods, hitting the officer in the shoulder. The officer survived.
Zachary Evetts, Autumn Hill, Savanna Batten, Elizabeth Soto and Meagan Morris were sentenced to 50 years in prison. Maricela Rueda, another demonstrator, was sentenced to 70 years in prison. Benjamin Song, who fired the gun at the police officer, was sentenced to 100 years in prison.
The sentences handed down on Tuesday were unusually long, said Barbara McQuade, a former federal prosecutor who served as the US attorney for the eastern district of Michigan during the Obama administration.
Most often, judges will sentence defendants for separate counts concurrently. Here, it appears that the judge stacked the sentences for each count consecutively. I would have expected lengthy sentences here, more in the ballpark at 15 to 25 years, but nothing like 50 to 100 years, she wrote in an email.
area51
(12,792 posts)zilch for the Epstein-class rapists.
GenThePerservering
(4,097 posts)and damaged their property, Trump would have given them pardons and a couple of million dollars.
hookaleft
(1,400 posts)then they loosely associated everyone else at the protest with the shooter. What a bunch of bullshit. Fucking fascist pigs
hatrack
(65,370 posts)Shocking. Not.
LeftInTX
(34,959 posts)FORT WORTH Federal judges in Texas on Tuesday gave eight members of an alleged antifa cell prison sentences as long as 100 years for their roles last summer in a protest that turned violent outside an Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility.
https://wapo.st/4fX4q8x
FalloutShelter
(14,748 posts)Murderers get lighter sentences. Shit in the Capitol and beat Police officers and get pardoned.
ProfessorGAC
(77,681 posts)I can't condone the actions they took beyond the 1st amendment protected protest, but 50 & 75 years is utterly preposterous.
MustLoveBeagles
(18,332 posts)tanyev
(49,945 posts)raccoon
(32,502 posts)Torchlight
(7,238 posts)they'd be standing in line for hand-outs from the admin and starting book tours about now.
Klarkashton
(5,517 posts)Sending a goddamn "message"
Lives ruined for the sake of trump and his bastard army.
TommyT139
(2,505 posts)Two of those convicted are trans women. Their chances of surviving in a men's prison, or surviving solitary confinement with a shred of sanity intact, are slim. Those are effectively sentences of torture.
And one of the guys, a husband of one of the protesters, wasn't even there.
The ninth defendant, Daniel Sanchez-Estrada was not at the protest, but was convicted of corruptly concealing a document or record after prosecutors said he moved leftwing zines and other materials at the request of Rueda, his wife, after she was arrested. Sanchez-Estrada was sentenced to 30 years in prison on Tuesday.
https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jun/23/prairieland-ice-protesters-texas-sentenced
This is a war, being fought unilaterally.
Diraven
(1,968 posts)For rearranging magazines on a coffee table? There's no way that's not getting overturned in appeal.
TommyT139
(2,505 posts)Evidently the terrorism add-on is a wild card, and also a key factor being that the materials were made of paper?!? They made the comparison to J6'ers, who of course destroyed papers, including those belong to congresspeople, as well as their pathetic attempts to delete the incriminating evidence they themselves posted.
We'll see how it goes, but based on how the one-sided war has gone so far, they seem to be winning. Judges can have their say, until either an appeal goes in favor of the trumpists, or it gets to the SC, where Shadow Docket and Stall go trump's way.
DoBW
(3,397 posts)enough said
told the pardoned J6 rioters and insurrectionists that "acceptance of a pardon is an admission of guilt?
TommyT139
(2,505 posts)...getting pardons that it's essentially a rebranding. Plus they're getting millions of dollars, besides having any financial penalties forgiven.
You know, "War is Peace. Freedom is Slavery. Ignorance is Strength."
Pardons are prizes.
hookaleft
(1,400 posts)I hate them so much.
hookaleft
(1,400 posts)spanone
(142,249 posts)Picaro
(2,453 posts)Texas has a long history of these kinds of sentences and worse.
maxsolomon
(39,430 posts)He did 15.
This is cruel and unusual punishment.
LeftInTX
(34,959 posts)Martin68
(28,303 posts)maxsolomon
(39,430 posts)I think these were State charges so it's going to be tough for an appeal to succeed.
Poor fuckers. Guns make everything worse.
LeftInTX
(34,959 posts)FORT WORTH Federal judges in Texas on Tuesday gave eight members of an alleged antifa cell prison sentences as long as 100 years for their roles last summer in a protest that turned violent outside an Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility.
https://wapo.st/4fX4q8x
Most often, judges will sentence defendants for separate counts concurrently. Here, it appears that the judge stacked the sentences for each count consecutively. I would have expected lengthy sentences here, more in the ballpark at 15 to 25 years, but nothing like 50 to 100 years, she wrote in an email.
Federal courts have sentencing guidelines. I don't know what the guidelines are for consecutive versus concurrent. So, they might be able to appeal the sentencing.
Bluetus
(3,312 posts)Yes, the sentences seem unduly harsh. But I'm not sure we want people like this on our side.
hookaleft
(1,400 posts)they were just around the few that were.
Bluetus
(3,312 posts)I agree that some of them got a tough deal, and will probably get reduced ssentences on appeal. But I can't stand up for somebody vadalizing property and certainly not somebody shooting from a sniper's postion.
RoeVWade
(965 posts)nt*
LeftInTX
(34,959 posts)Two Trump appointees. O'Connor is a Bush appointee. It's in the district where the crime occurred.