Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Ocelot II

(130,842 posts)
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 11:27 AM 14 hrs ago

Another ICE outrage:

Last month, Meenu Batra, 53, who has lived in the South Texas border colonia of Laguna Heights since 2002, was on her way to Milwaukee, Wisconsin, to work another case. She’s been a court interpreter for over 20 years, the only one licensed in Texas for Hindi, Punjabi, or Urdu. Her language skills are requested nationwide, where she’s contracted to help people making their way through the immigration court system, just as she did for herself 35 years ago when she immigrated from India to New Jersey before settling in Texas.

She planned to meet with her adult children in Austin after the Wisconsin trip, the only difference she foresaw in an otherwise typical trip. Her routine for years included flying from either Harlingen or Brownsville to far-flung parts of the country where South Asian immigrants needed language access. For this trip, the flight was out of Harlingen.

But, around 5 p.m. on March 17, Batra was detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents after passing through security at Harlingen International Airport. In a sworn deposition that was filed as part of a petition for habeas corpus—a legal request to be released on the grounds that the detention is unlawful—Batra said the people who arrested her did not have visible badges nor were they wearing uniforms. One of those agents had asked Batra if she knew she was in the country illegally and that she had a deportation order. She replied that her work authorization status, which she applied for regularly after being granted a legal status called withholding of removal by a New Jersey immigration judge decades ago, was good for another four years.

“That doesn’t mean you can be here forever,” the agent replied. Two more plainclothes agents would join the two that detained her, bringing her down the escalator and to the front of the airport.

https://www.texasobserver.org/immigration-court-interpreter-arrested-ice-south-texas-airport/

We're just deporting the worst of the worst, right?

29 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Another ICE outrage: (Original Post) Ocelot II 14 hrs ago OP
Frighten, disadvantage, apply nonsensical illegal treatment because their King says so. Passages 14 hrs ago #1
DURec leftstreet 14 hrs ago #2
From my self defense class: never engage. Don't answer any questions. Don't talk. Anything you say will cbabe 14 hrs ago #3
This is a great video about why you never talk to the police. Phoenix61 13 hrs ago #4
I doubt refusing to talk would work with ICE. ShazzieB 12 hrs ago #14
Not every tactic works every time. If you notice, bad cbabe 11 hrs ago #16
Excellent points! ShazzieB 11 hrs ago #17
"Sit down, make them carry you." ShazzieB 11 hrs ago #15
Unfortunately... GiqueCee 12 hrs ago #5
K&R Solly Mack 12 hrs ago #6
Worst of the worst means darkest of the dark to MAGA. ChicagoTeamster 12 hrs ago #7
Collateral damage. gulliver 12 hrs ago #8
All ICE agents hired after January 19, 2025, shold be at a minimum investigated, prosecuted and jailed as KPN 12 hrs ago #9
Her son is in the US army: cbabe 12 hrs ago #10
A Republican official and several judges want her released muriel_volestrangler 12 hrs ago #11
The ACLU popsdenver 12 hrs ago #12
ACLU doesn't take individual cases, and most of these matters are handled locally. Ocelot II 12 hrs ago #13
A massively popsdenver 10 hrs ago #19
HIRING the worst of the worst, to victimize the EASIEST of targets. Grokenstein 11 hrs ago #18
There are no guidelines or adherence to the law these purported federal agents choose to follow. BeneteauBum 7 hrs ago #20
Spread the word. yellow dahlia 7 hrs ago #21
Video interview with her children: IcyPeas 6 hrs ago #22
All part of the darkness and filth the Pope was talking about Blue Owl 6 hrs ago #23
K&R. nt Wednesdays 4 hrs ago #24
ICE is being run by a bunch of ignorant, ill-trained thugs. progressoid 3 hrs ago #25
I always tell people apply for permanent residence status and citizenship somsai 3 hrs ago #26
Her "withholding of removal" status did not allow her to apply for permanent residence dalton99a 3 hrs ago #28
Kick dalton99a 3 hrs ago #27
Most of these people are life losers that know nothing about the law JI7 2 hrs ago #29

cbabe

(6,701 posts)
3. From my self defense class: never engage. Don't answer any questions. Don't talk. Anything you say will
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 11:37 AM
14 hrs ago

be used against you. They aren’t interested in your answers or having a conversation. It lets bad guy move in close to hurt you.

Scream fire. Better response than calling for help.

Call 911 immediately for kidnapping.

Take photos if you can.

Get their dna if you can.

Sit down, make them carry you.

Don’t obey in advance.

Phoenix61

(18,855 posts)
4. This is a great video about why you never talk to the police.
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 12:26 PM
13 hrs ago
?si=TLqyJ4ZfwIQ8adZZ

ShazzieB

(22,716 posts)
14. I doubt refusing to talk would work with ICE.
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 01:37 PM
12 hrs ago

They don't follow any of the rules actual police follow.

cbabe

(6,701 posts)
16. Not every tactic works every time. If you notice, bad
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 02:04 PM
11 hrs ago

guys use talk to give them time to circle and capture. It’s not about words.

Don’t give them that time.

Bad guys also use words as justification for their actions. Like a bar fight stirring up trouble. ‘What are you looking at…?’

Don’t give them the justification.

ShazzieB

(22,716 posts)
15. "Sit down, make them carry you."
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 01:48 PM
11 hrs ago

During the nonviolent protests of the civil rights movement, demonstrators were trained to do just that (among other things). Don't fight back; just become dead weight so that police literally have to carry you. Make them do all the work.

It was effective then, but I have no idea how well it would work with ICE.

https://www.crmvet.org/info/nv1.htm (see item F.3.)

GiqueCee

(4,462 posts)
5. Unfortunately...
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 12:56 PM
12 hrs ago

... the Worst Of The Worst are the ones doing the deporting. They are malignant filth with no redeeming qualities whatsoever. To dispose of them in a toxic waste dump would be an insult to toxic waste. They're arresting journalists for doing their jobs, and getting away with it! The list of their crimes is endless.

gulliver

(14,031 posts)
8. Collateral damage.
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 01:03 PM
12 hrs ago

I really don't know why I don't see us doing the obvious. Dems should be running to the front of the pack, loudly vowing to "rid the country of the worst of the worst." That would be political judo and help us get a leg up on the immigration issue. Instead, we let the showboats get on camera and yell "ICE out!" to the choir.

All that does is give ammunition to the opposition. This poor lady, then, ends up paying the price.

KPN

(17,441 posts)
9. All ICE agents hired after January 19, 2025, shold be at a minimum investigated, prosecuted and jailed as
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 01:06 PM
12 hrs ago

appropriate for any violations of individual's constitutional rights on US soil.

That's the least a civilized society can do to right the wrongs that have been carried out against them by this foul administration and its criminal goons.

cbabe

(6,701 posts)
10. Her son is in the US army:
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 01:10 PM
12 hrs ago

Newsweek
https://www.newsweek.com › ice-arrest-immigration-court-interpreter-us-army-texas-mom-india-11837423

ICE Arrest Immigration Court Interpreter With Son in US Army

3 days agoA longtime immigration court interpreter has been detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). Meenu Batra, 53, an interpreter

muriel_volestrangler

(106,360 posts)
11. A Republican official and several judges want her released
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 01:18 PM
12 hrs ago

As the only authorised court interpreter for 3 major languages, I'm not surprised. She is a vital part of Texas justice.

Batra’s habeas petition included dozens of letters from people in her community and beyond asking for her to be released from detention. Cameron County Precinct 1 Constable Norman Esquivel, a Republican elected official and fixture in Laguna Madre-area politics, and several judges across the country are among those who authored a letter.

She is exactly who a sensible country would be falling over themselves to give citizenship to.

popsdenver

(2,399 posts)
12. The ACLU
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 01:26 PM
12 hrs ago

should establish a "hot line" for reporting and publicize it for analysis of immediate action needed.
Start to hire and spread ACLU attorneys across every state who can respond immediately to any they deem necessary....
And throw a monkey wrench in their corrupt and illegal charades.......

I can only imagine, if the ACLU did something like this, and appealed for donations from all of us, that we all would donate immediately and keep on donating, rather than funding a do nothing group of our current politicians.......
There have to be good attorneys in every state that we and the ACLU could pay to assist in this war....

Ocelot II

(130,842 posts)
13. ACLU doesn't take individual cases, and most of these matters are handled locally.
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 01:35 PM
12 hrs ago

Here in Minneapolis, for example, there is a collective of volunteer lawyers who take habeas cases for ICE detainees. There are probably organizations like that all over the country. The National Immigration Law Center has a list of resources on its website. https://www.nilc.org/request-for-legal-assistance/#what-we-work-on

popsdenver

(2,399 posts)
19. A massively
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 02:48 PM
10 hrs ago

coordinated effort by the ACLU may be a start to waging war.......The constant bombarding of the courts........

As it is now, and has been, the Republicans across the nation are continuously burying the courts with their bullshit, and it is working to slow us down........

BeneteauBum

(602 posts)
20. There are no guidelines or adherence to the law these purported federal agents choose to follow.
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 05:56 PM
7 hrs ago

Peace ☮️

somsai

(245 posts)
26. I always tell people apply for permanent residence status and citizenship
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 10:11 PM
3 hrs ago

The test is extremely easy and it only takes a few years. She would have been a citizen 30 years ago unless there is an arrest or something we don't know about. Being familiar with our courts I'm sure she knew all the particulars of laws here and there. Some countries don't allow citizens of other countries to own land.

dalton99a

(94,712 posts)
28. Her "withholding of removal" status did not allow her to apply for permanent residence
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 10:35 PM
3 hrs ago
People who are granted withholding of removal are typically immigrants who face persecution in their home countries, like those who receive asylum. Batra, who is Sikh, left India after her parents were murdered during a state pogrom against Sikhs in the 1980s. Batra did apply for asylum but instead received withholding, which, unlike asylum, does not come with a path to a green card.

JI7

(93,755 posts)
29. Most of these people are life losers that know nothing about the law
Sun Apr 19, 2026, 10:48 PM
2 hrs ago

they have been rejected from real law enforcement jobs and they just hate most people of color.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Another ICE outrage: