Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Celerity

(52,141 posts)
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 09:51 AM Yesterday

Can The Left Have a Kirk?



https://washingtonspectator.org/can-the-left-have-a-kirk/

https://archive.ph/omZXL



A day after Charlie Kirk’s mega-funeral—which corralled tens of thousands of young people, far right politicians, a roster of Christian Nationalist pastors and an otherwise distractible president, all into an Arizona stadium—political pundits on the left are already wondering: Can we have a Charlie Kirk? If you believe that Kirk’s inflammatory rhetoric towards Black women, trans people, and a whole host of other Americans he openly despised was his main appeal, then you have your answer: No.

But I spent countless hours with Charlie Kirk, his donors, co-workers and members of his loyal fan base while writing my book Raising Them Right, the Untold Story of America’s Ultraconservative Youth Movement and its Plot for Power, a narrative account of how the modern conservative youth movement was birthed; and while I found his hateful rhetoric increasingly distasteful and ultimately very frightening, I don’t actually think hate was his main appeal.



More central I think was Kirk’s understanding of what today’s generation of anxious, rudderless young people want —and need. If the broad—and increasingly hapless—coalition that makes up the American left wants to cultivate a young charismatic personality prepared to spread the pro-democracy, anti-MAGA message, that person will need to follow a few guidelines that Kirk and the multitude of donors who generously supported him understood to be essential. Hate does not have to be part of the equation.

Offer A Road Map

For the modern GOP, Charlie Kirk was a powerful political strategist. But for his young fans, he was first and foremost a motivational speaker, who carried his MAGA message to them through a self-empowering focus on bettering their own lives. Kirk, who had 5.4 million followers on X, did a hefty amount of political ranting about diversity initiatives, overly woke campuses, “sick” gender confused young people, and the war in Gaza – usually blaming some subset of the Democrats and/or minorities whom he spoke of in the cruelest of terms.

snip
18 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Can The Left Have a Kirk? (Original Post) Celerity Yesterday OP
We are not sheep, so I doubt it. GreenWave Yesterday #1
Bernie isn't exactly chopped liver. no_hypocrisy Yesterday #2
No. yardwork Yesterday #3
I vote no. Girard442 Yesterday #4
We already have. Norbert Yesterday #5
Do you mean before or after his apotheosis? EYESORE 9001 Yesterday #6
Kirk punched down, not up leftstreet Yesterday #7
I think that because of social media markodochartaigh Yesterday #8
No, because a know nothing blow hard backed by Johonny Yesterday #9
It seems to me a complicated question. Raven123 Yesterday #10
Yes SocialDemocrat61 Yesterday #11
I doubt conservative and religious colleges would allow a progressive on campus to berate/debate students thebigidea 23 hrs ago #12
No way, no how. (nt) Paladin 23 hrs ago #13
We have AOC and Jasmine Crockett Jilly_in_VA 23 hrs ago #14
Too many lefties are educated. A Larry "Lonesome" oasis 23 hrs ago #15
True liberalism easily can. gulliver 22 hrs ago #16
Whenever I hear someone ask, "Why doesn't the left have a [insert right wing figure] of their own?" Tommy Carcetti 22 hrs ago #17
It's like a medical researcher saying, why don't we have any GOOD treatments that are as aggresive as sepsis. Girard442 22 hrs ago #18

yardwork

(68,143 posts)
3. No.
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 10:00 AM
Yesterday

Charismatic speakers selling neo-traditional "values" are the antithesis of what we need in a democracy.

Girard442

(6,767 posts)
4. I vote no.
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 10:20 AM
Yesterday

Kirk may have had a plethora of other talents, but without the hate, his operation would be a car with no gas in the tank -- a fancy-shmancy park bench.

Norbert

(7,387 posts)
5. We already have.
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 10:28 AM
Yesterday

JFK, RFK & MLKjr. Kirk couldn't come close to topping the least of these three.

EYESORE 9001

(29,074 posts)
6. Do you mean before or after his apotheosis?
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 10:31 AM
Yesterday

I vote ‘no’ on any arrogant, supercilious demagogue speaking on my behalf.

leftstreet

(37,370 posts)
7. Kirk punched down, not up
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 10:32 AM
Yesterday

Kirk was the antithesis to class solidarity

The Democrats don't need an equivalent to that

markodochartaigh

(4,150 posts)
8. I think that because of social media
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 10:35 AM
Yesterday

Kirk's reach was greatly amplified. And the social media algorithms which allowed this amplification are heavily weighted towards the extreme right by the techbros who own the platforms. It seems to me to be analgous to Hearst egging on the Spanish American War.

Johonny

(24,772 posts)
9. No, because a know nothing blow hard backed by
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 10:37 AM
Yesterday

Last edited Sat Sep 27, 2025, 12:05 PM - Edit history (1)

A billionaire is unlikely to become popular on the left.

Are their popular left leaning influrencers. Yes there are. Will they get the amount of main streaming as Kirk? No, because there aren't the billionaires on our side.

Raven123

(7,075 posts)
10. It seems to me a complicated question.
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 10:40 AM
Yesterday

From my view, an honest discussion may not be easy on DU, as it might require an open and harsh assessment of missed opportunities.

thebigidea

(13,532 posts)
12. I doubt conservative and religious colleges would allow a progressive on campus to berate/debate students
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 10:49 AM
23 hrs ago

Once or twice but certainly not for years of propaganda

oasis

(52,946 posts)
15. Too many lefties are educated. A Larry "Lonesome"
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 11:25 AM
23 hrs ago

Rhodes type will never woo them into his tent.

gulliver

(13,520 posts)
16. True liberalism easily can.
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 11:59 AM
22 hrs ago

And we really should focus on that. Democracy matters. One person has one voice. People are good, and even if they're not, they're the people. What they want the world to be like is what it should be like.

I'm increasingly impressed with what I see from Gavin Newsom and John Fetterman, and that's in the leadership department. There are many others.

Can we get a Kirk? Absolutely. We could get a bunch of them. The resistance to an effective, pushy, debating, true fighter of the left would all come from people who are not true fighters (and, therefore not really even truly left). You're not a true fighter if all you do is pick stupid fights and lose them all the time. You're a true fighter if you smile when attacked. You're true fighter if you get in fewer fights because people respect you. You tell true fighters by whether or not they win.

Tommy Carcetti

(44,234 posts)
17. Whenever I hear someone ask, "Why doesn't the left have a [insert right wing figure] of their own?"
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 12:03 PM
22 hrs ago

I always think about this scene from O Brother Where Art Thou? where Governor O'Daniels' advisors asks why his campaign doesn't have their own little person on the campaign trail like his opponent Homer Stokes does.

Girard442

(6,767 posts)
18. It's like a medical researcher saying, why don't we have any GOOD treatments that are as aggresive as sepsis.
Sat Sep 27, 2025, 12:45 PM
22 hrs ago

Couldn't happen. Sepsis is inherently bad.

Search instead for therapies with high success rates, minimal side effects, and that don't break the bank. Then promote them.

And throw a baker's dozen of snake oil salesmen under the bus.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Can The Left Have a Kirk?