Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

uponit7771

(93,252 posts)
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:10 AM Sep 19

Who was worse? Nixon or Trump?

It seems like Nixon had a whole a-hole rap sheet too along with a cult following

Seems like the difference was congress cared about being re-elected back then and kept Nixon from going wild.

Was Nixon worse than Trump and what are the material high level changes between congress now and then?


Trying to get a historical perspective


Thx in advance

66 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Who was worse? Nixon or Trump? (Original Post) uponit7771 Sep 19 OP
Trump by far! DemMedic Sep 19 #1
Trump is far worse. OLDMDDEM Sep 19 #9
Oh, hell no. Nixon had NOTHING on Trump. Granted R's in Congress actually had some ethics hlthe2b Sep 19 #2
I watched the Nixon bio on PBS the other night LeftInTX Sep 19 #23
Who was worse? trump, by a mile. (nt) Paladin Sep 19 #3
Not even close. yardwork Sep 19 #4
It has to be trump, right? EnergizedLib Sep 19 #5
Let's see: EPA, first rise in minimum wage in decades, attempted Equal Right Amendment, Voting rights amendment, ... marble falls Sep 19 #6
See my post #12 Fiendish Thingy Sep 19 #13
Yeah, MAGA would hate him ... So he tried some progressive policies uponit7771 Sep 19 #32
He felt he had been cheated out of offices, and he seemed to have little no qualms about dirty tricks himself ... marble falls Sep 19 #40
Minimum wage was raised twice during each of Kennedy's and Johnson's terms RazorbackExpat Sep 20 #46
Nixon was pretty bad, but there were a few lines even he wouldn't cross. Ocelot II Sep 19 #7
Obviously he's a piece of shit is worse but the only reason Eliot Rosewater Sep 19 #8
Right, trump said smart people don't like him uponit7771 Sep 19 #33
Hands down Trump. He is the worse but I think Reagan and "W" Bush were also worse than Nixon. walkingman Sep 19 #10
Trump Wifes husband Sep 19 #11
Trump is clearly more corrupt and incompetent Fiendish Thingy Sep 19 #12
Reagan interfered with US negotiations on the hostages from the Embassy. So Carter couldn't claim that ... marble falls Sep 19 #41
Nixon actually did a lot of good things. Turbineguy Sep 19 #14
Compared to tRump Nixon is a God worthy of worship and prayer. nt ImNotGod Sep 19 #15
that's not even a marginally valid question. try again. - -(nt)- stopdiggin Sep 19 #16
We literally stopped working and danced n the aisles when Dick resigned. Ping Tung Sep 19 #17
Hell when pedoprez dies there'll be parties worldwide!!! uponit7771 Sep 19 #34
I have seen four republican presidencies Cosmocat Sep 19 #18
I think you've seen six jmowreader Sep 19 #39
Dubya was a sociopath who delighted in signing death warrants RazorbackExpat Sep 20 #48
Trump, by a mile! LeftInTX Sep 19 #19
Yep, that does it .. Trump lying about the virus for months is some top line evil shit uponit7771 Sep 19 #35
Trump. lostincalifornia Sep 19 #20
Trump ArnoldLayne Sep 19 #21
I long for Richard Nixon synni Sep 19 #22
Literally pining JCMach1 Sep 19 #25
Trump Rebl2 Sep 19 #24
Trump makes Nixon videohead5 Sep 19 #26
Well, there's this.. surfered Sep 19 #27
Trump! I despised Nixon, but I would gladly trade Trump for him. rsdsharp Sep 19 #28
Trump by far. Nixon was an amateur compared to Trump. And the American people had a moral core back then. Irish_Dem Sep 19 #29
Nixon was way worse. valleyrogue Sep 19 #30
Well said. Nixon's legacy includes many thousands dead in SE Asia and here. Ping Tung Sep 19 #38
Richard Nixon wasn't totally subhuman as Trump is. I remember after he left office the revered Vermont Vinca Sep 19 #31
Ah, so Nixon had a heart underneath being an asshole... Trump is a pile of shit no matter what uponit7771 Sep 19 #36
Remember, too, that Nixon left office after a group of Republicans went to the White House and told him Vinca Sep 19 #37
I think the GOP wants to keep him to be president forever! IzzaNuDay Sep 20 #59
Different perspective from the other responses FHRRK Sep 20 #42
Is this serious? iemanja Sep 20 #43
I was a child when Nixon was president, and the world wasn't falling apart around me. Crunchy Frog Sep 20 #44
When Agnew resigned in disgrace in 1973 DFW Sep 20 #45
Nixon was elected for two reasons Norbert Sep 20 #47
What's worse? A bad flu or stomach cancer? Tommy Carcetti Sep 20 #49
+1 dalton99a Sep 20 #63
We're experiencing the most corrupt government in our nations history. Emile Sep 20 #50
Trump rapes little girls, unlike Nixon Blues Heron Sep 20 #51
trump wins this one. badhair77 Sep 20 #52
Nixon was an altar boy next to trmp. spanone Sep 20 #53
Reagan, Dubya and Trump are on my top 3 list. tavernier Sep 20 #54
Nixon hid by appearing to be liberal. Got a lot of liberal support to get elected. tirebiter Sep 20 #55
Trump is so much further down the fascist trail that Nixon just stepped on. lark Sep 20 #56
Sorry, but that isn't even a serious question. Ferrets are Cool Sep 20 #57
Nixon v Trump Mike Nelson Sep 20 #58
Nixon was cheating at Tiddlywinks Freddie Sep 20 #60
Nixon tried his hand at a few progressive policies xmas74 Sep 20 #61
Trump is orders of magnitude worse. Trump is in his own category dalton99a Sep 20 #62
Trump rso Sep 20 #64
trump. Nixon for all his faults and vile nature, was as times politically pragmatic. themaguffin Sep 20 #65
You're joking. No comparison. madibella Sep 20 #66

hlthe2b

(111,464 posts)
2. Oh, hell no. Nixon had NOTHING on Trump. Granted R's in Congress actually had some ethics
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:15 AM
Sep 19

and asserted themselves--at least ultimately back then. But, I don't even think Nixon would have imagined 1% of what Trump has already pulled. And, Nixon had a conscience (not a 100% amoral sociopath).

Watergate? Quaint compared to what Trump has already done in first term, much less now.

LeftInTX

(34,006 posts)
23. I watched the Nixon bio on PBS the other night
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 12:45 PM
Sep 19

I was literally crying because I was longing for the good old days.

When I first watched it in 2012, I thought, "He sure was corrupt". "I'm glad we got him". "Breaking into a psychiatrist's office to steal Daniel Ellsberg's medical records is about the lowest you can go"

Now I'm like, "We've got King Kong in office and we can't control him".

It's amazing what Trump has done to this country in just a few months.

yardwork

(68,143 posts)
4. Not even close.
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:18 AM
Sep 19

Trump is next level bad.

Nixon would be considered a flaming liberal by today's MSM and most of Congress.

marble falls

(68,722 posts)
6. Let's see: EPA, first rise in minimum wage in decades, attempted Equal Right Amendment, Voting rights amendment, ...
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:21 AM
Sep 19

... beat OPEC (with Sadam Hussein's help), tried to sponser with Teddy Kennedy a national health care system, Watergate.

Trumps worse by a mile. Trump is more a Harding than a Nixon.

Fiendish Thingy

(20,854 posts)
13. See my post #12
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:35 AM
Sep 19

On the evil scale at least, Trump isn’t ahead “by a mile”.

But he clearly wins the gold for corruption and incompetence.

marble falls

(68,722 posts)
40. He felt he had been cheated out of offices, and he seemed to have little no qualms about dirty tricks himself ...
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:19 PM
Sep 19

... eliminate the kneeling in prayer with Henry Kissinger in a hall somewhere in the White House. Attempting to lock a race he was going to win handedly, ignore that. He certainly was no TACO.

RazorbackExpat

(621 posts)
46. Minimum wage was raised twice during each of Kennedy's and Johnson's terms
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 04:35 AM
Sep 20

Nixon raised it once, 3 months before he resigned.

Ocelot II

(127,423 posts)
7. Nixon was pretty bad, but there were a few lines even he wouldn't cross.
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:22 AM
Sep 19

Despite his authoritarian tendencies, when SCOTUS ordered him to turn over the secret tapes he complied, knowing the likely consequences. He resigned when threatened with impeachment. He didn't do or say embarrassing things in foreign countries and he understood how to behave in public (though he drank a lot in private). He was duplicitous and sneaky but he wasn't stupid. He lied sometimes, but not all the time, and his public statements were coherent even when he was lying. He had three dogs.

Eliot Rosewater

(34,167 posts)
8. Obviously he's a piece of shit is worse but the only reason
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:23 AM
Sep 19

He was impeached wasn’t because the GOP wanted to do the right thing at all, they were just afraid of their base at that time.

Today they are not afraid of the base unless they go against the piece of shit.

I will keep saying it if we keep bringing a rolled up newspaper to a nuclear war going to get the same results.

Fiendish Thingy

(20,854 posts)
12. Trump is clearly more corrupt and incompetent
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:33 AM
Sep 19

But as far as evil goes, Nixon did sabotage the peace talks that could have ended the Viet Nam war before the 1968 election, and then ordered the bombing of Cambodia, which destabilized that nation, leading to the Pol Pot genocide…and it was on Nixon’s watch that the CIA assassinated Allende and installed Pinochet in Chile.

marble falls

(68,722 posts)
41. Reagan interfered with US negotiations on the hostages from the Embassy. So Carter couldn't claim that ...
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:35 PM
Sep 19

... before the election. When Reagan won, he immediately got back the remaining hostages. Nixon's policies weren't unilateral regarding Viet Nam, a lot of popular support and a military that kept it going. Nixon had some moderate leanings for a Republican.

I think this is what really defeated him in 1960 was his doing this live TV all during the Kennedy/Nixon debate:

Turbineguy

(39,432 posts)
14. Nixon actually did a lot of good things.
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:45 AM
Sep 19

He was re-elected by a landslide. He wanted universal healthcare.

If it weren't for Watergate, he would have been pretty good.

On the other hand there's trump. The opposite end of the spectrum. What a fucking loser.

Ping Tung

(3,708 posts)
17. We literally stopped working and danced n the aisles when Dick resigned.
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 11:59 AM
Sep 19

I'm way to old to do much dancing but I could manage a gleeful hobble if Donnie was kicked out.

Cosmocat

(15,290 posts)
18. I have seen four republican presidencies
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 12:08 PM
Sep 19

Nixon had a duality.

As others noted, he handled himself with grace while the cameras were on or in public. And, he actually had some decent domestic policies.

But, underneath it all, he was a very insecure and angry person. He was in office at at time when there was still some sense of honor in our politics and again with the duality, he was shady and pushed and crossed over the limits when he could get away with it, but in the end ceded to the norms of society at the time.

Reagan was a hateful ideologue who put his acting experience to great benefit with the gee, golly good guy act. He was truly masterful as an orator and public figure and just had a presence that related to a lot of people at the time. As opposed to Nixon fighting with liberal democracy, he cut it out at the knees making it normal to question government while also helping to lead republicans in learning how to normalize and deliver hate speech in a way that they could wink at those who it appealed to while seeming to be innocuous (ex. welfare queen).

It ground my gears that W was a mostly feckless arrogant lightweight son of privilege. But, compared to what came both before and after him, he was not a hateful person. He meant well, but bought into the right wing bullshit and let the usual suspects he brought in do the dirt on the sly.

DT ... No words needed.

jmowreader

(52,678 posts)
39. I think you've seen six
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 04:07 PM
Sep 19

If your first one is Nixon, the others are…

Gerald Ford: Ford understood his primary job as president was getting rid of the scum Nixon put into the government. He did semi-OK, but for some reason he kept Kissinger.

Reagan: Committed treason to get into office. Once he was there he went on a serious crime spree. Until Trump was elected Reagan stood as our most corrupt president.

Bush 41: More of the same.

Bush 43: Dubya’s biggest problem is he tried to president the way he governed Texas. The Texas system is set up so the Lieutenant Governor has more power than the Governor. I wonder what he’d have been like if he’d have told Dick Cheney, “no, you’re not my running mate.”

Trump: His political heroes are all dictators, and he’s working hard to become one himself. Definitely America’s worst leader, and quickly becoming the world’s worst leader.

RazorbackExpat

(621 posts)
48. Dubya was a sociopath who delighted in signing death warrants
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 04:51 AM
Sep 20

He also pushed through the "Patriot" Act in the wake of 911.

Dubya was the "who cares what you think" "president" and called the Constitution "just a goddam piece of paper".

Dubya lied about seeing a tower being hit on live TV in the elementary school.

He joked about the non-existent WMDs after bombing the shit out of Innocent Iraqis.

And don't get me started on that election that his dumbass brother helped rig for him in Florida.

LeftInTX

(34,006 posts)
19. Trump, by a mile!
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 12:33 PM
Sep 19

I survived Nixon, but was too young to vote. Life was pretty much status quo during his term. Johnson was president from when I was in second through eighth grade. Nixon was eighth through senior year. To me, the country was pretty much the same with both presidents. There was more turmoil during Johnson's presidency. Nixon's crimes were white collar and under the radar and took alot of digging to find out. Trump is "out there" crazy.

Trump wants to destroy the country.

Nixon was corrupt.

Rating of GOP Presidents in my life
Ford
Bush (1989) (tie)
Nixon (tie)
GW Bush
Reagan
Trump

Eisenhower was president when I was born, but I don't remember him, so I can't rate him. Most rank Eisenhower as the best GOP president of the past 100 years.

Nixon is pretty much tied with the George HW Bush in my book.

Reagan was worse than Nixon
Trump is worse than Reagan

Trump's first term his harm was more on par with Reagan's harm. (Although different)

This term, he's much worse than Reagan.

synni

(555 posts)
22. I long for Richard Nixon
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 12:44 PM
Sep 19

Those were the good old days, when a crooked politician knew it was time to resign.

Rebl2

(17,010 posts)
24. Trump
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 01:04 PM
Sep 19

by far! At least I don’t think he threatened our first amendment rights. He didn’t threaten to revoke the license of networks or make threats against comedians (because they said not so flattering things about him) that I am aware of.

Irish_Dem

(75,315 posts)
29. Trump by far. Nixon was an amateur compared to Trump. And the American people had a moral core back then.
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 01:30 PM
Sep 19

They were horrified by Nixon's crimes.

Trump is much much worse and the majority of Americans either agree with this crimes
or don't give a damn.

valleyrogue

(2,340 posts)
30. Nixon was way worse.
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 01:35 PM
Sep 19

People seem to forget he, through third parties, sabotaged the 1968 Paris Peace Talks that would have ended the Vietnam War, thus not just ensuring his re-election, but he stretched that war out unnecessarily to ensure his re-election. Hundreds of thousands of people died simply because Nixon wanted to gain and keep power. Watergate was in large part a result of Nixon's paranoia of being found out for having violated the Logan Act.

Nixon should have been tried at The Hague.

Trump is an idiot who has truly evil people in charge of running things, but Nixon stands alone with his treachery. Nixon was vastly more intelligent than Trump. However, his mental problems concerning hate against his perceived enemies was his downfall.

People tend to forget how devastating the Vietnam War was to people's faith in our country's institutions. Ditto for Watergate. These set the stage for the mess we have today.

Ping Tung

(3,708 posts)
38. Well said. Nixon's legacy includes many thousands dead in SE Asia and here.
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 03:27 PM
Sep 19

People should remember The Wall and remember LBJ and Nixon as war criminals.

Vinca

(52,738 posts)
31. Richard Nixon wasn't totally subhuman as Trump is. I remember after he left office the revered Vermont
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 02:51 PM
Sep 19

Senator George Aiken (who famously said about Vietnam we should declare victory and get out) was on his deathbed in a small, Vermont hospital and Richard Nixon showed up to visit him. All the way from California. Trump would only visit a dying colleague if it meant a photo op and good press.

uponit7771

(93,252 posts)
36. Ah, so Nixon had a heart underneath being an asshole... Trump is a pile of shit no matter what
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 03:13 PM
Sep 19

Vinca

(52,738 posts)
37. Remember, too, that Nixon left office after a group of Republicans went to the White House and told him
Fri Sep 19, 2025, 03:22 PM
Sep 19

to step down, otherwise he would be impeached. Do you think Trump would step down? I imagine his fat, orange ghost will haunt the White House for the next 200 years.

IzzaNuDay

(1,146 posts)
59. I think the GOP wants to keep him to be president forever!
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 10:12 AM
Sep 20

Even if it’s a weekend at Bernie’s!

FHRRK

(1,209 posts)
42. Different perspective from the other responses
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 01:37 AM
Sep 20

Is Trump the worst? On policies and actions, no question.

With that Trump doesn't exist without Nixon, Reagan and the Bush's and without the Republican party of the last 75 years.

Change order of birth and I would say, other than George HW Bush, they all would be as shitty if not worse.

George W is the least likely, but dumb as a rock so he gets mention. The remaning two, just as bad as tRump.

DFW

(58,999 posts)
45. When Agnew resigned in disgrace in 1973
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 03:52 AM
Sep 20

Nixon picked a decent, competent VP who could actually take over without the country falling apart (Gerry Ford). Storm clouds were already gathering, and Nixon knew he might not complete his second term, even though in 1973, it didn’t yet look imminent. At least he cared about the country’s continuity. JD Vance is the choice of someone who does not.

Norbert

(7,387 posts)
47. Nixon was elected for two reasons
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 04:45 AM
Sep 20

1. LBJ was not getting us out of Vietnam
2. Chicago.

There were still several moderate Eisenhower Republicans in Congress that would hold Nixon accountable. Even the conservative GOP know when it was time to cut bait about Watergate.

trump has ne guard rails. Almost all of the GOP side of congress is with him all the way and will do ANYTHING to keep him in power. I don't think that Nixon could ever get away with blowing up boats in Venezuela, at least not in the era that he rose to power.

Emile

(37,789 posts)
50. We're experiencing the most corrupt government in our nations history.
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 08:07 AM
Sep 20

Trump will go down in history as the worst president ever!

badhair77

(5,002 posts)
52. trump wins this one.
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 08:21 AM
Sep 20

Nixon was awful and villainous but an amateur compared to trump. Nixon wanted power but trump wants it all, power, money, revenge, attention, and the list goes on, plus he’ll do anything to get it. He’s lined up a group of warriors and cronies willing to assist in that endeavor.

tavernier

(13,966 posts)
54. Reagan, Dubya and Trump are on my top 3 list.
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 08:28 AM
Sep 20

I don’t think Nixon caused the damage those three did. He was just a crooked politician. Those three caused many to die.

tirebiter

(2,643 posts)
55. Nixon hid by appearing to be liberal. Got a lot of liberal support to get elected.
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 08:31 AM
Sep 20

Nixon tried to hide his tracks by appearing to be the liberal version of Nixon. Luckily people like Panetta saw him for what he did. Panetta had to drop out, became a Democrat, then got elected to the House and came back to help take down Nixon.

lark

(25,496 posts)
56. Trump is so much further down the fascist trail that Nixon just stepped on.
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 09:01 AM
Sep 20

Trump - Worse Person in the World since Hitler.

Mike Nelson

(10,763 posts)
58. Nixon v Trump
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 10:01 AM
Sep 20

... Nixon had more of an adherence to a set of norms and morals, in my opinion. Trump has a set (the so-called Christian right), but he seems to only use them for political gain.

xmas74

(29,951 posts)
61. Nixon tried his hand at a few progressive policies
Sat Sep 20, 2025, 10:22 AM
Sep 20

Seemed to care at least a tiny bit about foreign policy and at least didn't directly talk shit about the military, possibly because he served. He also actually loved his wife and children and liked animals.

Nixon was the better person.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Who was worse? Nixon or T...